The Keefe Report: “In Your Eyes”—Glock MHS Protest Rejected

posted on June 7, 2017

Well, it’s official. The U.S. Army has given Glock it’s MHS mix tape back. At least for Glock, the MHSthe big Modular Handgun System trial to determine the next 9 mm service pistol of the U.S. military—is over.

A variant of SIG Sauer’s P320 pistol was awarded the XM17 contract on Jan. 19, 2017, and Glock filed a protest with the Government Accounting Office (GAO) in late February. As part of the U.S. government procurement system, such protests are very common. Now that the protest, which the GAO had until June 5 either to accept or reject, has been denied, at least the bare bones of what Glock was protesting have been announced.

This was released by the GAO and reported on “On June 5, 2017, the U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) denied a protest filed by Glock, Inc. … The protester challenged the Army’s interpretation of the solicitation regarding the minimum number of contract awards required by the RFP. The protester also alleged that the Army improperly evaluated its proposal. The maximum contract value, including all options, is approximately $170 million.

“GAO denied the challenge to the interpretation of the solicitation, finding that the RFP allowed the Army to make only one award, although up to three awards were permitted by the RFP’s terms. GAO also denied the challenge to the Army’s evaluation of Glock’s proposal on the basis that any errors did not prejudice Glock in the competition.

“GAO’s decision expresses no view as to the merits of the protester’s proposal. Judgments about which offeror will most successfully meet the government’s needs are reserved for the procuring agencies, subject only to statutory and regulatory requirements, such as full and open competition, and fairness to potential offerors.”

Will Glock stand outside in the rain on the lawn of Project Manager Soldier Weapons with its boom box blaring like something out of a John Cusack movie from the 1980s? No. While surely disappointed, it’s not like Glock is on the brink of insolvency. It was worth a try. This protest was as natural as dirt and as expected as dawn. Glock, of course, still has an open contract with SOCOM and just landed a big, fat FBI contract.

“By not completing the testing on both proposals on a competitive basis, the Army never determined which pistol would better meet the warfighter's needs,” said Glock’s Vice President Josh Dorsey in a June 7 press release. “We are confident had the Army completed the testing, the GLOCK 19 would have outperformed the Sig P320, as it had in recent testing conducted by a leading federal law enforcement agency which resulted in GLOCK, Inc. being awarded that contract. GLOCK pistols have been battle proven by select units of the U.S. military forces for the past 10 years. GLOCK, Inc. stands with the men and women serving in the Armed Forces and will continue to give them its full support.”

Dorsey added, “We thank our technical team for submitting a pistol that met or exceeded all of the Army's requirements. We also extend our appreciation to our MHS partner, Vista Outdoor's Federal Cartridge, for creating the most effective and innovative pistol round we have ever tested, which performed flawlessly in the GLOCK 19 MHS model.” That Vista was Glock’s MHS partner has not widely been reported.

There is a very big story when it comes to the MHS ammunition side. The new ball XM1152 is said to fulfill the Army’s requirement for “increased performance.” Too, there is a new “Special Purpose” (meaning “hollow-point”) round, the XM1153, waiting for a legal interpretation on its use on the battlefront.

The Army, SIG Sauer and Winchester Ammunition, have all been very tight lipped. Now that the Glock protest has been resolved, it is my hope that the Army and the companies involved will be more forthcoming with information. This is the biggest military handgun story in a generation.

The good news for consumers is that Glock’s MHS, entrant—the G19 MHS—may join two other outstanding handguns that did not win the contract—the FN America 509 and the Beretta APXon the commercial market.

Additional Reading:
The Keefe Report: Army XM17 MHS Pistol—It's Happening  
The Keefe Report: Proven—The FN America 509 Pistol   
FN America Launches MHS Entry: The 509 9 mm Pistol   
MHS Update: Glock Protests SIG Sauer Result   
Beretta Introduces the APX   
Winchester Named Ammo Supplier for the U.S. Army MHS Program  
NRA Gun Gear of the Week: U.S. Army’s New Pistol  
The Keefe Report: I Was Wrong About the XM17  
The Keefe Report: SIG Sauer Wins U.S. Army XM17 Modular Handgun System (MHS) Contract  


right side bolt-action rifle gray wood silver metal steel stainless
right side bolt-action rifle gray wood silver metal steel stainless

NRA Gun of the Week: Kimber 84M Pro Varmint

On this week’s “Gun of the Week” video preview, watch as American Rifleman staff take a short-action Kimber 84M rifle to the range for discussion.

The Armed Citizen® Oct. 15, 2021

Read today's "The Armed Citizen" entry for real stories of law-abiding citizens, past and present, who used their firearms to save lives.

Rifleman Q&A: M1 Garand Vs. M1 Carbine Rebarrels

It seems to me that few World War II-vintage M1 Garand rifles retain their original barrels today, whereas most M1 Carbines of the same era I have seen still have the original barrels?

Record Setting Participation In USA Clay Target League Fall Season

This fall season of the USA Clay Target League has reached new heights, with a record breaking 651 high school and college teams, equating to 11,783 of the young enthusiasts, participating.

NRA Museums: 85 Years Of Preserving The Past For The Future

In June 1923, the Official Journal of the National Rifle Association became The American Rifleman, a bi-monthly publication with a staff that included Maj. Julian S. Hatcher, Lt. Col. Townsend Whelen, Capt. Charles Askins, Sr. and a host of others whose names read like a who’s who of legendary gun writers and experts.

Savage A17: The Semi-Automatic .17 HMR Rifle

Introduced in 2015, the Savage A17 rifle line was one of the first semi-automatics to be chambered for the tiny but hot .17 HMR cartridge. 


Get the best of American Rifleman delivered to your inbox.