Alexander Hamilton's Pistols Sold At Auction

by
posted on June 3, 2021
** When you buy products through the links on our site, we may earn a commission that supports NRA's mission to protect, preserve and defend the Second Amendment. **
Three Days In May
Two flintlock pistols that sold at auction and once belonged to Alexander Hamilton
Photo courtesy of Rock Island Auction.

A pair of flintlock holster pistols presented to Alexander Hamilton—founding father, Declaration of Independence signer and American patriot—sold at Rock Island Auction on May 14, the first of the company’s three-day event last month.

Hamilton’s flintlock pistols are .58-cal. and have 9” round barrels. Stocks are made from walnut, and the finish is brightly blued. General Philip Schuyler presented the guns to Hamilton after the Battle of Saratoga. The matched pair features light floral engraving, the barrels are smoothbore and furniture is brass.

The pistols remained in his family for 150 years, until they were finally sold in the 1940s. The authenticity of the pistols is well documented and includes notarized affidavits. During the Revolutionary War, only two Founding Fathers served in the Continental Army with distinction—George Washington and Hamilton, according to Rock Island Auction’s website.

The first day also saw a J. Ulrich exhibition relief-engraved Winchester Model 1873 rifle. The gun was originally commissioned as a display piece for the 1876 Philadelphia Centennial Exhibition—celebrating the 100th anniversary of the signing of the Declaration of Independence. The President of Honduras presented it later to Winchester.

Notable firearms also sold include Bat Masterson’s Colt Single Action Army, a Confederate Columbus Arsenal 9-lb. cannon and a French Model 1857 “Napoleon” 12-lb. cannon. Hamilton’s pistols sold for a hammer price of $1.5 million, while Bat Masterson’s Colt sold for $488,750. The two cannons sold for $661,250 and $138,000, respectively.

Rock Island Auction’s next auction takes place June 10 to 12, and more than 5,500 guns are already listed for the event.

Photo courtesy of Rock Island Auction.

Latest

Springfield Armory SA-35 4"
Springfield Armory SA-35 4"

Review: Springfield Armory SA-35 4"

Springfield Armory has made its SA-35 High Power clone even more appealing to those interested in a compact, concealed-carry pistol with a new 4-inch barreled version of its SA-35.

Legacy Sports International Expands Howa Bolt-Action Rifle Lineup

Japanese-made Howa M1500 rifles continue to be some of the best value-for-the-money bolt-actions on the market, and for 2026, the company is adding two new models, along with a new chambering.

The Armed Citizen® Aug. 17, 2026

Read today's "The Armed Citizen" entry for real stories of law-abiding citizens, past and present, who used their firearms to save lives.

Skills Check: The Tabula Rasa Method

Too many shooters step onto the range carrying the emotional residue of every missed shot, every bad stage and every ugly drill from the last six months like a tactical backpack full of disappointment. The Tabula Rasa method is designed to change that relationship.

Canadian Law Enforcement Agencies Select Federal Ammunition

Federal Ammunition will supply the Canadian Department of National Defense and the Royal Canadian Mounted Police with rifle and shotgun ammunition, respectively.

Shooting Surplus: Finding Affordable Mil-Surp Ammo in 2026

Today, the market for mil-surp ammo is vastly different than it was even just a few years ago. If you're a military-surplus collector and shooter, what should you look for in 2026? Here's our guide.

Interests



Get the best of American Rifleman delivered to your inbox.