Rifleman Q&A: Short Or Long Frame Colt Stocks?

posted on June 10, 2022
Two colt revolver left-side view with grips stocks wood removed signify size difference compatibility.
The long frame Detective Special on the right was made in 1956, while the short frame version on the left was made in 1969. Notice how the protruding wood on the bottom of the short frame grip encloses the gun’s butt. Thus, these stocks will not fit a long frame Detective Special.

Q: What is meant by a Colt Detective Special short frame versus a Colt Detective Special long frame? I’m looking for a pair of original stocks for my Detective Special and keep coming across these terms. How does this affect the stocks?

A: There is a definite difference between “long frame” and “short frame” Colt Detective Special stocks. The Detective Special was made from 1927 until 1995, and during that period, four different changes, or “issues,” as collectors call them, were produced that will dictate the type of stocks used for each gun.

The first issue (1927-1933) featured a long, squared-off butt profile, and the stocks used on these guns will not fit any of the subsequent issues and are not referred to as either long- or short-frame stocks.

In 1933, Colt rounded off the heel and toe of the gun’s steel butt, and guns with this grip profile—which includes second-issue (1947-1965) variations—have become known as long frame Detective Specials.

In 1966 (the beginning of the Third Issue Detective Special), Colt shortened the lower portion of the Detective Special’s frame, allowing it to be used on some of Colt’s other D-frame revolvers, such as the Colt Agent and Cobra. This has now become known as the short frame Detective Special and is easily identified by the fact that the two-piece walnut stocks designed for the short frame cover up the bottom section of the revolver’s grip area. Thus, they will not fit the previous long-frame versions, in which the steel butt is exposed.

Despite the differences between the short and long frames, using the correct factory stocks on each will result in grips of the same overall length.

Short-frame stocks will also fit Fourth Issue Detective Specials (1973–1995) and other late D-frame Colt revolvers. So, it is important that buyers source stocks specifically for either a long frame (1933-1965) or a short frame (1966-1995) Detective Special, depending on which version they have.

—Rick Hacker, Field Editor


Clandestine 1911 Bonavita
Clandestine 1911 Bonavita

Colt's Rarest Clandestine Pistol?

According to advanced Colt collectors, only about 35 or so of the original 400 factory Colt 1911s chambered for .38 Super have surfaced in the United States postwar, with only about a dozen of those remaining in their issued condition with their original finish, and given that the war officially ended on August 14, 1945, and since the OSS was dissolved on October 1, 1945, it isn’t likely any of them were issued before the Armistice. 

New For 2023: Taurus 917C

Taurus is re-introducing a Beretta 92 clone in the form of its 917C, and this compact variant provides a "Commander-sized" option for fans of the DA/SA semi-automatic pistol.

Preview: Springfield Armory Hellcat Pro 17-Round Magazine

Springfield Armory’s Hellcat Pro is a slightly larger, yet still easily carried, version of its micro-compact Hellcat for personal defense, and the gun’s flush-fit magazine capacity was also increased to 15 rounds.

Gun Of The Week: Browning X-Bolt Target Max

Watch American Rifleman staff on the range this week to get a close look at an improved X-Bolt rifle from Browning. The Target Max is the latest iteration of the famed X-Bolt action, and it’s designed for long-range work, thanks to its Target Max customizable stock, adjustable trigger, bull barrel and more.

The Armed Citizen® Dec. 1, 2023

Read today's "The Armed Citizen" entry for real stories of law-abiding citizens, past and present, who used their firearms to save lives.

Review: Mag-Na-Port Custom Ruger Blackhawk Convertible

The author found the just-right performance and managed recoil balance he was looking for with this fully customized single-action wheel gun.


Get the best of American Rifleman delivered to your inbox.