The Keefe Report: XM17—As Big a Deal as the M9?

by
posted on January 31, 2017
** When you buy products through the links on our site, we may earn a commission that supports NRA's mission to protect, preserve and defend the Second Amendment. **
m9.jpg

Have you heard? SIG Sauer of Newington, N.H., has been awarded the biggest U.S. Army pistol contract in more than 30 years. And it is the first time a polymer-frame, striker-fired, double-action-only gun has been adopted as the standard sidearm for American soldiers.

It has been a long time since the United States military declared a new service pistol. Of course, there was the decision to adopt the U.S. Model of 1911 pistol back in 1911. Then in the late 1920s, the Army just adopted the M1911-A1 without much fanfare (while keeping the M1911 in service). John Browning's masterpiece continue to serve until 1985 when the Beretta Model 92FS was adopted as the U.S. Pistol M9. That was followed up by the adoption of the SIG Sauer P226 as the US M11. As good as the M11 was, it was not the standard sidearm. 

Getting the XM17 contract no doubt will benefit SIG Sauer beyond the actual number of guns supplied to the army over the 10-year contract span.

But will the coattails of the army pistol contract have as much influence in the market as the M9 did for Beretta back in the 1980s? I would say not. This is a very different era in terms of handgun ownership, use and decision-making then were the 1980s. Back then, American law enforcement was in the middle of the transition from double-action revolvers to semi-automatic pistols. Many agencies had not yet converted, and the adoption of the Beretta no doubt influenced a lot of police agencies. And frankly, there were just not that many semi-automatic pistols available in 1985. Now there are literally dozens and dozens of very good full-size and compact double-action 9 mm pistols.

While no doubt some police agencies will weigh the XM17 contract heavily in their decision to buy new pistols, likely those most influenced by the decision will be foreign governments that are our allies around the world. If you operate with U.S. troops into combat theater, it is nice to be able to rely on the U.S. military's logistics train for parts, magazines and ammunition, as well as American armorers. At the battalion level there will certainly be armorers that can fix any problems that might come up with a handgun. That is the same reason why some American special forces gave up on exotic personal guns and just went with the US M9. If you break something, it's nice to just get parts and service from a local line unit.

Another thought: Much has been made over the fact that SIG Sauer is a foreign company. While SIG is owned by German partners, when it comes to handguns SIG is a very American company. Except for small specific German police contracts, all SIG Sauer handguns are made in New Hampshireby American workers in an American factory. SIG Sauer has transitioned away from manufacture in Germany. And the P320 was jointly designed by American and German engineers, and was prototyped and tested right here in the United States. Perhaps it is just one more sign of a global economy.

Top: Department of Defense image

 

 

Latest

Christensen Arms Evoke Review 1
Christensen Arms Evoke Review 1

Christensen Arms Evoke: A Budget-Friendly Hunting Rifle Built For The Field

For hunters seeking a well-built, no-frills hunting rifle, the Christensen Arms Evoke offers a host of desirable features, all at a price that leaves room for hunting tags and travel costs.

Wholesale Change in Glock Lineup & Other Industry Moves

Fall 2025 has proven to be a volatile time within the firearm industry, with companies like Glock announcing major changes to its product lineup, while other companies announce expansions and moves.

I Have This Old Gun: Model 1895 Lee Navy Rifle

In the 1890s, U.S. military small arms were evolving rapidly. The recent discovery of smokeless powder, along with the development of new operating systems and cartridge designs, led the U.S. Navy to adopt a radically new platform: the Model 1895 Lee Navy rifle.

Carry Comped: Smith & Wesson Performance Center’s Compensated Bodyguard 2.0 & Shield X

Smith & Wesson introduced compensated models of two popular concealed-carry handguns in its lineup, the Bodyguard 2.0 and Shield X, both designed to help handgunners improve recoil control.

An Appendix-Carry Primer

Although appendix inside-the-waistband carry of a defensive handgun has become increasingly popular, it remains controversial among some concealed carriers. Here, an AIWB practitioner outlines its pros and cons.

Favorite Firearms: A Hero’s War Trophy Returns

My father, Kenneth Cuddeback, graduated from high school in West Chester, Iowa, in 1942 and started at Iowa State University in the fall. When two of his high school friends were going to get drafted, he quit college to join the Army.

Interests



Get the best of American Rifleman delivered to your inbox.