Rifleman Q&A: Mysterious ‘Trapdoor’

posted on April 25, 2023
1870 Springfield Officer’s Model Carbine

Q: I have what I believe to be an 1870 Springfield Officer’s Model Carbine. What I have researched is that these rifles were converted from caplock to a centerfire mechanism, and vernier sights were added. The rifle I have is converted from flintlock using a similar, if not the same, mechanism for firing centerfire cartridges. The only marking is found at the top, rear of the breech and it reads:
“Model 1870.”

I cannot find a single callout in Flayderman’s reference book or the NRA museum website. Is my conversion authentic?

A: You have an interesting piece. “Trapdoor”-style rifles and carbines have regularly been altered to look like flintlock muskets and rifles, blunderbusses and even pistols by the motion picture industry for use as prop guns. These conversions are generally fairly crude (only good enough to look good on camera) and are normally undertaken using later arms chambered in .45-70 Gov’t. in order to take advantage of readily available blanks. 

Your piece, on the other hand, it being a Model 1870, is most probably chambered in .50-70 Gov’t., unless it has been re-chambered. The work appears to be of excellent quality; I have never seen anything quite like it and can only opine that the work was likely undertaken by some gunsmith or talented hobbyist who wanted to fire a “flintlock” without all the attendant bother. The fact that the piece also has an anachronistic, vernier-style rear tang sight indicates that it was intended for shooting rather than just for show.

—Garry James, Field Editor


Colt Gold Cup National Match 1911 Rifleman Review 3
Colt Gold Cup National Match 1911 Rifleman Review 3

Rifleman Review: Colt Gold Cup National Match

When Colt's Paul Spitale arrived at the company, his mission was to develop a refined version of the Colt Gold Cup National Match M1911. The pistol here is exactly what he came up with, and it harkens back to the glory days of Colt's classic guns.

New For 2023: Taurus GX4 Carry

Taurus expanded its GX4 line of guns in 2023 with the addition of a "Carry" model, built with a longer barrel and extended grip frame.

Favorite Firearms: The Lost Rifle That Finally Came Home

It’s the early 1950s, and my dad is about 12 years old. He’s hunting rabbits in an overgrown field near his house using a Stevens Model 87A. It’s almost dusk, and rain clouds are looming overhead.

Remington Recalls Core-Lokt Tipped Loads

A safety recall has been issued by Remington Ammunition for three lots of Core-Lokt Tipped Remington .300 Win. Mag. cartridges. Affected lot numbers are N16OCA373, N17OAA373 and N22OCA373 and bullet weight is 180 grains.

Rifleman Q&A: Browning “Salt Wood” Stocks

I’ve always wanted a Browning Superposed shotgun, but I’ve heard of a stock issue involving salted wood. What happened, and is it still a problem?

I Have This Old Gun: British Pattern 1851 “Minié” Rifle-Musket

Though its active official service life was less than a half-dozen years, Britain’s Pattern 1851 “Minié” rifle musket was an important step in the evolution of military longarms.


Get the best of American Rifleman delivered to your inbox.