Cowboy Collecting

by
posted on May 3, 2013
** When you buy products through the links on our site, we may earn a commission that supports NRA's mission to protect, preserve and defend the Second Amendment. **
wiley-clapp.jpg

From just before the American Civil War to just after the turn of the century, America underwent a westward expansion unparalleled in history. Millions migrated with the sun to the new opportunities beyond the wide Missouri. In order to have this happen, the frontier population went armed with the fast-developing firearms of that day. In our time, this movement has been romanticized heavily, including the use of a wide variety of guns. The process has involved a great many so-called “western” motion pictures and TV shows. This, in turn, has created a demand for shooting samples of all of these types of guns. I’m delighted to point out that you can now buy brand-new examples of almost all of the guns that served to conquer the frontier. Made of modern steels and fitted very nicely, these guns come from a variety of factories, most of which are in Italy.

While long arms of many brands are available (including such gems as Sharps and Spencers), we’ll stick with the handguns. Some of the very earliest revolvers were imported from Italy by Val Forgett in the late ‘50s. They were the black powder, caplock revolvers of Colt and Remington. The Colts were in greater variety and are still available for those fond of shooting cap-and ball guns. Eventually, other black powder guns came along, including the ’58 Remington and even the exotic LeMat.

The vast majority of Frontier cartridge revolvers were made by Remington, Smith & Wesson and of course, Colt. The ever-popular Colt Peacemaker has been replicated in virtually every one of its major variations—Bisley, Flat Top, Storekeeper’s, Buntline and others, and several varieties of Remington are available. Only fairly recently have the difficult-to-make breaktop series of S&Ws come on the market. Called the No. 3 model, there are four major revolvers in the series—American, Russian, Schofield and New Model. Only the earliest—the Americans—have yet to be replicated. I was really pleased to see the No. 3 New Model in the Taylor's & Company catalog at SHOT this year.

It remains for a domestic replicator to come up with a working model of the Merwin, Hulbert revolver. This Frontier period gem is intricate and finely fitted, but a delightful revolver with many desirable features. An American entrepreneur is said to be hard at reproducing this gun and I wish him the best of luck.

Latest

2026 New Suppressor Guide
2026 New Suppressor Guide

New Suppressors for 2026: A Full Guide

With the removal of the $200 NFA tax stamp on suppressors, the only sound reverberating across the firearms landscape is “cha-ching.”

MDT Now Offering Lone Peak Arms Rifle Actions

Earlier in 2026, MDT announced that it had acquired Lone Peak Arms, and now, the company's rifle actions are available to consumers.

The Armed Citizen® Aug. 31, 2026

Read today's "The Armed Citizen" entry for real stories of law-abiding citizens, past and present, who used their firearms to save lives.

Review: TriStar KR.22

Manufactured by Kral Arms in Turkey, the TriStar Arms KR.22 is a lightweight semi-automatic that offers everything you need to get started or to perfect what you’ve learned over the years.

Safe Space: 5 Must-Have Accessories to Organize Your Gun Safe

It's a perennial problem for gun owners: not enough safe space. Here are five organizing products that will help you squeeze a bit more in your existing gun safe before you have to run out and buy another.

EAA's Witness2311 CMX XXX & SC9 XXX: A More Practical 2011 Design?

New for 2026, EAA Corp. is downsizing the Witness 2311 CMX design with the CMX XXX and SC9 XXX, two handguns that are built around an entirely new magazine.

Interests



Get the best of American Rifleman delivered to your inbox.