The Keefe Report: What Consumers Want in a Concealed-Carry Pistol

by
posted on January 31, 2020
** When you buy products through the links on our site, we may earn a commission that supports NRA's mission to protect, preserve and defend the Second Amendment. **
keefshiel.jpg

If there was any doubt about the current ascendancy of the 9 mm Luger cartridge and other must-have features in a CCW gun, I would point to Exhibit A. That would be the gun I reviewed in the pages of American Rifleman: the Smith & Wesson M&P9 Shield EZ.

Smith & Wesson had so much success with the .380 ACP version of this gun (reviewed here) it had to dedicate considerable resources to keeping up with demand. Going down in cartridge performance allowed the gun to be very easy to operate, but some consumers were unwilling to take that step down in power.

Smith was asked almost immediately when it could have a 9 mm ready. And now we have our answer. Not even two years after we reviewed the .380, we have the production 9 mm in hand. No offense to my friends at Smith & Wesson, but this is like turning on a dime for them.

While the operating system remains the same, there was much engineering that needed to be done to accommodate the higher pressures and energy of the 9 mm Luger cartridge. A whole new frame had to be designed and molded—a not insignificant cost, even when you do it yourself as S&W does—a new magazine had to be created, and the mass of the slide and the recoil spring configuration had to be adjusted and tuned.

If you read the story, we get into the gun, but we did not spend a lot of time discussing the consumers embracing this new class of handgun. More and more Americans are choosing to arm themselves daily for personal protection, and while micro guns such as the new Springfield Hellcat and SIG Sauer P365 are current category leaders—perhaps even defining their own category—there are some armed citizens who simply prefer other features.

I am not at all condemning this new generation of micro compacts—I have an optics-ready model on order—but there is a parallel trend toward guns like the EZ, and it is based upon ease-of-use and operation as well as multilayered safety features.

With the EZ, there is a grip safety that is very, pardon the pun, easy to disengage. That’s because it does not require much pressure, and it is hinged at its bottom. I’ve encountered no one handling either the .380 or 9 mm who has had difficulty depressing that grip safety. But what that safety does is ensure that this hammer-fired gun is seriously drop-safe. Without that grip safety depressed, you cannot connect the trigger bar to the sear.

Another reassuring safety feature for those interested in the EZ are the bilateral manual safeties. Multiple sources report that nearly three-quarters of .380 EZ buyers wanted the manual safety. They voted for it with their wallets and pocketbooks.

And then there is perception at the gun store counter. I have jested with friends that if you want to sell a polymer-stock bolt-action rifle at an average retailer, my advice would be to make sure it has a good trigger and a very smooth bolt travel. Because those are about the only two things you can learn about a rifle at the counter. And now I would add ease of racking the slide for a 9 mm pistol at that very same counter (even though proper technique can overcome just about any recoil or striker spring).

That’s because being able to competently operate the gun is one of the most important aspects of owning a personal protection handgun. If you can’t do it at the counter, you might not be able to do it when it really counts. A certain amount of confidence comes from knowing you can operate your gun regardless of your physical circumstance. And that is part of the EZs’ appeal. The guns aren’t for everyone—no one gun is—but the EZs sure seem to be the ticket for whole lot of individuals.

Latest

The Six Hour Gun 1
The Six Hour Gun 1

The Six-Hour Gun: Saving a Family Heirloom

Simple math would have told anyone it wasn't worth fixing a $150 revolver. But to one family, this simple, common revolver meant everything.

Idaho Voters Choose the Winchester Model 1873 for their Official State Firearm

On November 3, Idaho voters picked the Winchester Model 1873 rifle (nicknamed the “Gun that Won the West,” in .44-40 cal.) as the leading candidate to be their state firearm.

PROOF Research Opens New Montana Facility

PROOF Research held a grand opening of its new manufacturing facility in Columbia Falls, Mont. at the end of October.

Making the Smith & Wesson Bodyguard 2.0

After more than 10 years, Smith & Wesson discontinued production of its original M&P Bodyguard .380 and began plans for a second-generation model. But the path to the Bodyguard 2.0 wasn't a linear process.

NRA-ILA: Election Results Put Second Amendment Rights Under Immediate Threat

NRA-ILA Executive Director John Commerford issued a statement following the 2026 midterm election results.

Short & Fresh: The Derya TM22 Fresh & RANX Mag Fed

Derya Arms now offers two radical versions of several of its traditional firearms with the new TM22 Fresh and RANX Mag Fed pistols.

Interests



Get the best of American Rifleman delivered to your inbox.