Rifleman Q&A: Why So Light With The M1 Carbine?

by
posted on April 4, 2023
M1 Carbine
An early form of the personal-defense-weapon (PDW) concept, the M1 carbine provided more effectiveness than a pistol for military personnel whose duties precluded a standard service rifle.

Q: I know the M1 carbine was issued in large numbers during World War II but that it was considered to be under-powered. It seems our military would have been better served by a firearm of this type that had better performance. Why wasn’t this done?


Marine radio operator
A Marine radio operator at work on Iwo Jima keeps his carbine within easy reach.

A: The question must be asked, “under-powered” compared to what? The M1 carbine was initially developed to provide a firearm that could be carried by personnel such as ammunition carriers, machine gun and mortar crews, communication and administrative personnel, etc., whose duties precluded the issuance of the standard service rifle. Normally, such individuals would be armed with handguns, but the early success of the German Blitzkrieg and airborne tactics meant that such personnel could conceivably be confronted by hostile units at any time, so the Ordnance Dept. issued specifications for a “light rifle” that could be easily carried by such personnel but would be more effective than a handgun.

The specifications mandated that the weight of the firearm not exceed 5 lbs., yet have an effective range of at least 300 yards. Thus, the “light rifle,” which morphed into the M1 carbine, was developed, in large measure, as a substitute for the .45-cal. pistol. Except in very close-range encounters, such as two adversaries in the same foxhole, there is no doubt the carbine was the superior arm in regards to both accuracy and firepower. It is true that the .30 Carbine cartridge did not possess the close-range “stopping power” of the .45 ACP, but at ranges exceeding 25 yards, the .45’s close-range potency was essentially irrelevant, since the odds of a typical soldier hitting a target beyond that range were quite slim. On the other hand, at ranges up to 300 yards, the carbine was adequately accurate in the hands of anyone with a modicum of marksmanship training, while the .45 pistol would be absolutely useless.

.30-’06 Sprg. and .30 Carbine cartridges
The .30-’06 Sprg. and .30 Carbine cartridges are shown for comparison.

The M1 carbine proved to be a very popular firearm and was manufactured in greater numbers than any other American small arm of the war. It was eventually used by many front-line infantrymen who appreciated its light weight, handiness and firepower as compared to the much heavier M1 Garand chambered for the powerful .30-’06 Sprg. cartridge.

It is worthy of note that the overwhelming majority of complaints against the carbine by the men who used it was that it was not as accurate or powerful as the M1 rifle. There is no doubt this was the case, however, it is rather unfair to condemn a firearm because it was used in a role for which it was neither designed nor intended. Complaining that the M1 carbine didn’t have the power, accuracy or range of the M1 Garand is akin to denigrating a Ford F-150 pickup truck because it doesn’t have the same hauling capability as a Freightliner 18-wheeler tractor-trailer rig. Certainly, the carbine had its limitations, as do all firearms, but it did a very credible job if used within the parameters for which it was designed.

Latest

Almost Portable Mg08 Us Gi
Almost Portable Mg08 Us Gi

Almost Portable: The German MG08/15

The MG08/15 was not a good design for a “light machine gun,” but it was a design that was available when it was needed, and it was the first step in the German progression toward a universal machine gun.

Gun Industry Taxes Paid $17 Billion Toward Wildlife Conservation Since 1937

The National Shooting Sports Foundation announced in May 2024 that firearm and ammunition manufacturers have paid more than $17 billion in excise tax contributions to the Wildlife Restoration Trust Fund (WRTF) since its inception in 1937.

Rifleman Review: Silencer Central Banish 46 Suppressor

One of the most versatile options in Silencer Central's own line of suppressors is the Banish 46, rated for use on rifles chambered for .458 Win. Mag. or less.

New For 2024: Rock Island Armory 5.0E

Rock Island Armory's 5.0E is an "enhanced" version of its original 5.0 handgun introduced at the 2023 SHOT Show.

2024 Accessory Of The Year: MDT .308/6.5 Creedmoor Polymer AICS 3-Round Magazine

The AICS-pattern detachable box magazine has become an industry standard, but MDT upped the ante by creating a flush-fit version that makes AICS-compatible rifles even more sleek and trim.

Legendary Riflemaker Melvin Forbes Passes Away

Melvin Forbes, founder of New Ultra Light Arms and a pioneer in the building of light rifles, passed away at his Granville, W.V., home on June 5, 2024. He was 77 years old.

Interests



Get the best of American Rifleman delivered to your inbox.