Lethal Force and the Law at the Great American Outdoor Show

by
posted on February 10, 2016
lethalforce_2.jpg

Every 13 seconds in the United States a firearm is used in self-defense. And every time a firearm is used in self-defense, even just the brandishing of it, there will be an investigation.

Those are facts stated by defense attorney Sean Maloney during a “Lethal Force and the Law--Universal Concepts Gun Owners Must Understand” seminar presented at the 2016 Great American Outdoor Show. “If you ever find yourself in such a situation, will you be ready? Will you be ready for the aftermath of using lethal force? Who are you going to call?” he asked the audience. 

Maloney is a team member with Second Call Defense, an insurance-backed program that offers immediate support for gun owners who are forced to defend themselves or their family with a firearm. He has practiced law for nearly 25 years, the last decade of which has been almost exclusively in firearm-related law—including 2nd Amendment rights, firearm-related defense and federal NICS appeals.

Maloney said one of the first steps in mentally preparing for a potential future self-defense scenario is to talk to a local attorney familiar with the laws of your state. Self-defense laws can vary drastically from state to state, and Maloney cautioned that ignorance is not a valid defense.

“Be aware that in some states you legally have a duty to retreat. If you live in one of those states you can only legally resort to lethal force if there’s no other option available to you,” he said. “And the old defense of, ‘I didn’t know,’ doesn’t fly in a courtroom. Saying, ‘Well, it’s not that way in Pennsylvania,” isn’t going to work either.”

According to Maloney, lethal force is only permissible in cases where the actor is in fear of immediate, unavoidable death or serious bodily harm. However, this determination is ultimately subjective, as a situation that one person finds to be life threatening, another person may not, he said.

As such, if you ever find yourself in court defending the actions you took while defending yourself, he said it will be the job of the defense attorney to convince the jury that you acted in the same way that any “reasonable person” in the same situation would have.

Maloney also cautioned the attendees to limit what they say to the dispatcher after calling 9-1-1 to report an instance of armed self-defense. He said the human body undergoes a tremendous transformation following an intense interaction such as a self-defense scenario, and that this internal chemistry change makes you an unreliable eye witness who is better off keeping your mouth shut.

“If you’re ever forced to use a firearm to defend yourself you’re going to have a rush of adrenaline and your stress hormones are going to rise a lot; you’ll develop tunnel vision of the perceived threat, auditory exclusion, a loss of fine motor skills, memory loss and a skewed perception of time and space,” Maloney warned. “If you talk immediately following an incident you may not be accurate at all, so don’t talk. Don’t try to plead your case on the phone. It’s not that we want to lie, just that because of what is happening to our bodies, we lack the ability to accurately recount what just occurred—so don’t try.”

Maloney is a member of the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers and has served as an expert witness in multiple civil lawsuits related to firearms. He is also a member of the NRA Board of Directors, an Election Volunteer Coordinator with the NRA’s Institute for Legislative Action and a Certified NRA Instructor in multiple disciplines. 

Latest

Silhouette Shooting
Silhouette Shooting

South Of The Border Turkey Shoot

Along the U.S.-Mexico border where the cultures of the two nations merge, a sport-shooting game has emerged—the Silhoueta Shoot. Authors Ben Avery and Gene B. Crum take a close look and report their findings.

New For 2024: Traditions Pro Series

Despite its name and extensive line of traditionally styled muzzloaders, Traditions Performance Firearms is at the cutting edge of modern muzzleloading and hunting firearms. New for 2024, Traditions is adding Pro Series models to its most popular firearm lines.

Preview: High Standard Firearms History | A Collector’s Guide

For lead author John Currie, High Standard Firearms History: 1932-1984 Connecticut, A Collector’s Guide has been a work more than 30 years in the making.

Gun Of The Week: Rossi Brawler

"Adaptable" and "handy" are key words that best describe Rossi’s modern single-shot handgun. A spinoff of the Tuffy shotgun series, the Brawler delivers .410 bore performance in a handgun-size platform.

The Armed Citizen® April 12, 2024

Read today's "The Armed Citizen" entry for real stories of law-abiding citizens, past and present, who used their firearms to save lives.

Review: Tisas 1911 A1 ASF

A new Tisas take on an American military wartime classic is officially known to the public as the 1911 A1 ASF (Armed Services Family) pistol and is being brought to U.S. shores by SDS Imports.

Interests



Get the best of American Rifleman delivered to your inbox.