I Have This Old Gun ... Remington New Model 1889 Side-By-Side Shotgun

posted on September 5, 2017
1889.jpg

America’s oldest firearm company, Remington Arms, celebrated its 200th anniversary in 2016 with an impressive array of commemoratives. As pretty as they are, one of the most graceful 19th century firearms ever assembled by the original Ilion, N.Y., factory was the New Model 1889 side-by-side shotgun, with its twin, distinctively curved “C”-shaped hammers. This was the last of Remington’s exposed-hammer doubles, a series that started with the Model 1873 Whitmore “Hammer Lifter” that utilized a European-style, tang-mounted lever to open the breech and concluded with the Model 1889 that—while not the rarest—remains a classic example of late-Victorian American sporting shotguns.

With its matted rib, rebounding hammers, casehardened sideplates, hand-checkered pistol grip and fore-end with Deeley & Edge latch, plus sporting an extractor and choke bored for nitro or blackpowder 258" shells, the Model 1889 was the right shotgun at the right time. In 1888, E. Remington & Sons went bankrupt, and, after being purchased by firearm entrepreneur Marcus Hartley and partners, the Model 1889 was one of the first guns to bear the newly reorganized Remington Arms Co. stamp. A total of 134,200 of these popular shotguns were produced between 1888 (when the first 38 guns were shipped) and 1908.


The Model 1889 was offered in 10 and 12 gauges, with a 16 gauge brought out briefly; in addition, a few rare 28 gauges are known to exist. Barrel lengths were 28", 30" and 32". Seven grades were available, beginning with Grade 1 with decarbonized (fluid) steel barrels, Grade 2 sporting twist steel and Grade 3, and above, featuring Damascus steel barrels. Grades 4 and above had increasing amounts of engraving. The initial price for a Grade 1 was $14.95, a Grade 2 was $21 and a Grade 3 would set you back $23.

Unfortunately, this Model 1889 Grade 1 example was poorly stored, with portions of the upper barrels exposed to moisture. However, internally it is pristine, and there is enough original wood finish, casehardening and bluing remaining to indicate a judicious cleaning would result in a noticeable upgrade in condition. But even in its current state, it is easily worth $950 to $1,150. Interestingly, it was purchased at Lock Stock & Barrel online auctions (lsbauctions.com) for $880, proving that used gun bargains can still be found.

Gun: Remington New Model 1889 Shotgun
Chambering: 12 gauge
Serial Number: 2041XX
Manufactured: c. 1900-1901
Condition: 70 percent – NRA Good/Very Good (Modern Gun Standards)
Value: $950 to $1,150

Latest

1 MG42 Finn Main
1 MG42 Finn Main

"Hitler's Buzz Saw:" Wartime Assessments Of The German MG42 Machine Gun

The Maschinengewehr 42, more commonly called the MG42, was Germany’s final development in its longstanding “universal machine gun” concept. American GIs and U.S. Intelligence officers were discussing its capabilities even while fighting raged across Europe.

Winchester Goes Racing In 2025

Winchester will be featured on the No. 3 Chevrolet driven by Austin Dillon as a part of the Richard Childress Racing team during the 2025 NASCAR Cup Series season.

Rifleman Review: Taurus 605 T.O.R.O.

Taurus recently updated its popular 605 revolver with the ability to add a red-dot optic, thanks to a modified topstrap that accommodates an optic baseplate.

New For 2025: Mossberg 590 Professional Series

Mossberg expanded its 590 series of shotguns with all new Professional models, which undergo an "enhanced assembly and quality-control process."

C&H Precision’s Red-Dot Retrofits

The micro red-dot (MRD) craze is in full-swing and, several years in, it shows no signs of slowing down—to the point that most new semi-automatic pistol introductions, and even some revolvers, now come from the factory ready to accept such an optic.

Field Notes: Weatherby Mark V Live Wild

As multiple gunmakers hustled to produce 7 mm Backcountry prototypes in the weeks leading up to our hunt, it was lucky happenstance that Weatherby was first to the gate.

Interests



Get the best of American Rifleman delivered to your inbox.