Favorite Firearms: A Mystery Colt Single Action Army

by
posted on May 25, 2024
** When you buy products through the links on our site, we may earn a commission that supports NRA's mission to protect, preserve and defend the Second Amendment. **
Colt Single Action Army

Perusing an expired paper-edition Gun List several years ago, I came across an ad for this old 1880-1881 Colt Single Action Army. Can’t remember what I paid, but at that time, it was too cheap to believe it was still for sale. I believe it now to be a .44-40 Win. etched-panel gun, which, at the time, was basically unknown to me. I just wanted what I thought was a Colt SAA from what I considered to be the prime 1880-1881 cowboy years.

The revolver has a blackpowder screw frame with a bullseye ejector rod. The bore is surprisingly bright with heavy rifling, all the numbers match and the action is very tight. There is a noticeably darkened area of etched panel. The seller stated that it looked like it had ivory stocks, but he was sure they were plastic. I couldn’t believe anyone would custom-carve plastic stocks, and I was convinced they were authentic ivory—which it turns out they were. Upon its arrival, I was understandably ecstatic at my good fortune.

I’d love to track down and find out any information on the law-enforcement officer/sheriff carved into the stocks, but I figure that 140 years later, that info is probably lost to the ages, though it does seem to have a recognizable look to it. Unfortunately, I made an amateur’s mistake of changing out the ejector housing that was slightly damaged for a better one … oh well! Probably damaged from a buffaloing arrest. It’s truly an “if only it could speak” Colt!

—Ron Bellville

Latest

IHTOG 1854 Lorenz Jagerstutzen 1
IHTOG 1854 Lorenz Jagerstutzen 1

I Have This Old Gun: Model 1854 Lorenz Jägerstutzen

The Austrian Lorenz Jägerstutzen was a unique variant of sharpshooting rifle that made it stateside during the American Civil War.

SHIELD Sights Celebrates 40 Years of Red-Dot Optics Innovation

SHIELD Sights is celebrating its 40th anniversary, marking four decades of British engineering, innovation and contributions to the evolution of modern red-dot optics.

TX Maxed: The Taurus TXM in 5.7x28 mm and .22 WMR

Using its TX series architecture yet again, Taurus is adding the 5.7x28 mm and .22 WMR to its chambering options with the new-for-2026 TXM.

Review: Federal's 6.5 Creedmoor +Peak Ammunition

Federal’s new 6.5 Creedmoor +Peak takes a long-range staple even farther.

New for 2026: Pulsar Thermion 3 Riflescope

Pulsar’s newest thermal scope offers longer range, sharper detail and expanded functionality.

AKs In The USA: The Current State of the American AK Platform

Despite it being the primary rifle of the enemy for most of its existence, American shooters have nonetheless warmed to the AK platform, creating an unlikely love story.

Interests



Get the best of American Rifleman delivered to your inbox.