The Keefe Report: Christmas Arrives Early for the 101st as XM17s Are Issued

posted on December 1, 2017

In the words of Lt. Col. Martin O'Donnell of the 101st Airborne Division, “Christmas came early for the 101st.” And it came in the form of the U.S. XM17 and XM18 pistols under the tree. Santa, in the form of the Army’s Program Executive Office Solider, came down the chimney with more than 2,000 XM17s. On Nov. 28, the first 2,000 or so of the Army’s new pistols were issued to the 101st at Fort Campbell, Ky. And Army Chief of Staff Gen. Mark A. Milley was there, and reportedly smiling. General Milley, of course, wears the 101st’s “Screaming Eagle” patch on his right sleeve. (U.S. Army photo)

Subsequent to that fielding, I attended a media roundtable held by Program Executive Office Soldier, which included soldiers and civilians involved in the acquisition of the XM17, as well as representatives from SIG Sauer, the lead on the contract and maker of the pistol. Winchester Ammunition, which developed and makes the XM1152 115-gr. ball load and the 147-gr. XM1153 Special Purpose (JHP) load that will be issued with the new guns, was also present, represented by Glenn Weeks, who said that the new loads are 25 percent more effective than standard M882 ball, and the ammunition is nearly as big a story as the gun itself. But that is a story for another time. 

U.S. Army photo

Chairing the roundtable was Project Manager Soldier Weapons Lt. Col. Steven Power, and on the civilian side was Daryl A. Easlick, Deputy, Lethality Branch, Maneuver Center of Excellence (how’s that for a title of a very serious man with a very serious job?). And on the conference call were soldiers from the 101st Airborne who have actually been issued the gun. As discussed previously, soldiers like the gun. Not just because it is new, but because the Army knows what virtually every law enforcement agency and a lot of civilians have known for a while. With only a single trigger pull length and weight to train, you get better results more quickly than with a traditional double-action/single-action pistol. For soldiers, that means increased capability and increased lethality when they close with and destroy the enemy. 

Image copyright American Rifleman

The Master Gunner of the 101st Airborne Division SFC Andrew Flynn, who was part of the Lethality Working Group (again, great name) and has a few months experience with XM17, said, “This is an excellent weapons system for soldiers … we will be providing to the team leader and above. Soldiers who have never had one will be able to have this weapons system in their hands prior to this fielding will be able to and be more lethal with it with minimal training requirements.” There’s another story there about who in the infantry will be armed with the XM17 and why. But that will have to wait, too.

Soldiers at Fort Campbell are already taking advantage of one of the principal design features of the XM17, and that is that the “gun” is a chassis, and the grip frame itself is easily replaceable.
There are three different grip sizes specified as part of the XM17, small, medium and large. According to the soldiers themselves, the “large” results in a grip that’s just a little larger than the M9 pistol, the medium is a little smaller and the small is, well, a lot smaller. Based on the number of gloves and their sizes issued by the army, Lt. Col.  Power estimated probably 90 percent of soldiers will stick with the medium grip. In talking to 1st Lt. Andrew Borer, a platoon leader with Charlie Co., 506th Infantry Regt., 101st Airborne, he said “I shot my personal weapon with the medium grip. I found the smaller fit better, allowed more control.” His personal-issue XM17 is now wearing a frame with an “S” on it. As SIG Sauer’s Tom Taylor said, “Grip size may not just be about hand size,” as some shooters prefer a smaller or larger grip than their glove sizes would indicate. (U.S. Army photo)

Images copyright American Rifleman

There are some significant differences between the guns delivered to the Army, which still wear the XM17/XM18 designations until type classification, and the commercial SIG Sauer P320. The trigger components, as discussed in previous posts, are different. Long before the P320 Sharknado, SIG had delivered a trigger group to the Army that improved the pull weight and was drop safe not only in SIG’s testing but also in the Army’s testing. 

The XM17 has an ambidextrous thumb safety (more on that later), different coatings, different trigger components, and it has an anti-tamper plate on the back of the slide. 

This prevents those without a special tool from monkeying with the striker components. The sample I saw had one for the take-down lever, too, which will not be on the XM17 going forward.

The thing to remember about the adoption of the XM17 is the contract award was only made in January. In 10 months Army acquisitions has done something that it has never done before. And that is go from awarding the contract, to preliminary testing, to materials testing and then to the actual field—issuing the guns to soldiers in 10 months. Operational testing occurred at Fort Bragg in September. Those familiar with Department of Defense bureaucracy should find this nothing short of astounding. 

Judging from the first photos to emerge from Fort Campbell, though, it looks like Master Gunner Flynn and his training cadre will have some work to do with the troops on the XM17. If you look closely, you will see more than one soldier with his thumb bent and tucked up against the left side of the frame with his strong hand. (u.S. Army photos)

That’s probably because these soldiers have been issued nothing but the M9—a pistol that has its manual safety and decocker on the slide, not a feature the Army was looking for in its next handgun.

The XM17 has an ambidextrous manual safety mounted to the frame at the junction between the frame and slide. The soldiers need to know you can just put your thumb on top of it. It’s OK. John Moses Browning told us it was all right back in 1911.

Image copyright American Rifleman

Not to knock the M9, it has a sterling reputation for the reliability, and it's probably the most tested handgun ever used by American troops, but the location of its safety and decocker would not lend itself to placing one’s thumb over it. After listening to formidable SFC Flynn on the conference call, there is no doubt he has already addressed it with his troopers.

U.S. Army photo

Again, these were the first soldiers to shoot the XM17 for the public affairs cameras. They can be forgiven, and they, no doubt, will be well trained. Seriously, we don’t’ always expect those opening their presents early to read the manual before pulling the bows off and ripping open the Christmas wrap.

Additional Reading:
The Keefe Report: The SIG Sauer P320 Sharknado
The Keefe Report: MHS Update—Hey, Mikey, They Like It!   
Fear & Loading: Screaming Eagles To Get First XM17s  
Glock MHS Pistols Unveiled   
In Your Eyes: Glock MHS Protest Rejected 
Army XM17 MHS Pistol: It's Happening
U.S. XM17 MHS: It's the Hollow Points, Stupid  
MHS Update: Glock Protests SIG Sauer Result

Winchester Named Ammo Supplier for the U.S. Army MHS Program  
NRA Gun Gear of the Week: U.S. Army’s New Pistol  
The Keefe Report: I Was Wrong About the XM17  
The Keefe Report: SIG Sauer Wins U.S. Army XM17 Modular Handgun System (MHS) Contract


The Armed Citizen
The Armed Citizen

The Armed Citizen® Aug. 8, 2022

Read today's "The Armed Citizen" entry for real stories of law-abiding citizens, past and present, who used their firearms to save lives.

Preview: Sentry Hexmag SR-25/AR-10 Magazine

Already well-respected within the industry for its Hexmag AR-15 magazines, Sentry Tactical is now also producing larger detachable boxes compatible with .308 Win.-chambered SR-25/AR-10-platform rifles.

Review: Springfield Armory Emissary

The M1911 is a classic design that is continually being re-imagined, and the Springfield Emissary is proof that this can be done very well. This pistol is well-equipped for personal protection, but it also exudes such a sophisticated and modern look that we wouldn’t be surprised if users wanted to show it off.

The Thompson Submachine Gun: Model Of 1919

The Model of 1919 Thompson submachine guns were the first of their breed, but they were more of an evolutionary series than a “model.” With names like “Persuader” and “Annihilator,” these prototypes were the foundation of an American legend.

Preview: Sionyx Backcountry Adventure Kit

Sionyx, maker of high-quality digital night-vision (NV) cameras, is now offering the Backcountry Adventure Kit—a bundle that includes its Aurora Black color NV camera, its range-extending Illuminator Kit and more.

SCCY Firearms: Guns For Everyday Carry

The company’s exclusive focus is on producing budget-friendly and reliable pistols for concealed carry. Its first gun—the CPX-1—appeared in 2005, at about the time permit applications were just beginning their dramatic increase.


Get the best of American Rifleman delivered to your inbox.