Wiley Clapp: What Killed the Kimball .30 Carbine?

by
posted on June 27, 2017
kimball_lede.jpg

Images courtesy RockIslandAuction.com.

Many years ago, I was hard at work in a new dream job—I was a gunwriter. After using guns in a bunch of different ways for all of my adult life, I had blundered into a gig where I drove to a big seven-story building on the Sunset Strip in Hollywood. Five days a week, I made the trip, arriving early and spending the entire day writing various stories about handguns—and they paid me! It was a great spot for which I will be forever grateful, but the very best thing about that job was the doors that opened because I had it. Things like the time a leading collector offered to loan me a Luger Carbine for a shooting review. It should come as no surprise that I quickly accepted that offer. But on another occasion, I ended up shooting a gun that I would probably have been better off never taking to the range.

The handiness of the US M1 Carbine made it immensely popular during World War II and when the little .30 Caliber began to enter the surplus stores in the 1950s, it was well accepted. Since there was somewhat of an American tradition of handgun and carbine shooting the same ammunition, the idea of a .30 Carbine handgun was also well received. Bill Ruger brought out his Blackhawk revolver in this caliber and encountered some success. By the way, both Smith & Wesson and Colt experimented with big revolvers in .30 Carbine. However, it was far more likely that an automatic pistol format would be a greater commercial success. Eventually, this perceived demand would be filled by one of Harry Sanford's creations (AutoMag), but in the '50s it was a gun called the Kimball. That gun failed and disappeared.

That situation was reported in this blog just a while back, but I am raising the topic again. In the process of looking up some other point, I found some new information. The Kimball failed because it was a delayed blowback, a hopelessly lightweight way to make a .30 Carbine pistol. The means of delaying the breech was a grooved chamber. On firing, the cartridge expanded quickly into a shallow groove, delaying it briefly. When the short, half-slide made it all the way to the rear, it came up hard against a vertical lug in the receiver. Contemporary accounts said this lug sometimes cracked or snapped in half. This would allow the slide to part company with the remainder of the pistol, presumably with a good head of steam.

When I borrowed that gun for shooting, the guy who loaned it to me told me that he had fired the gun a good bit, but quit because of the alleged problem. I was cautious but proceeded with the shoot. It was accompanied by sharp reports and nasty recoil, but functioning was normal. My new information says that failed guns showed obvious damage to that recoil lug. The inventor of the piece was quoted as saying that he had to re-examine and correct the heat treatment. I took my specimen apart for cleaning and saw no damage.

Did I get one that was “fixed” and, if so, how? If that is true, misinterpreted history may have killed off a promising design. We'll never know—only 238 Kimball .30 Carbine pistols were ever made.

Latest

Don Troiani’s Paintings Of The Revolutionary War
Don Troiani’s Paintings Of The Revolutionary War

Liberty: Don Troiani’s Paintings Of The American Revolution

Noted artist and American Rifleman contributor Don Troiani will display some of his original artwork at his first-ever major exhibition, which is being hosted by the Museum of the American Revolution in Philadelphia, Pa. The exhibition opened Oct. 16 and runs until Sept. 5, 2022, in the museum’s first-floor Patriots Gallery.

Preview: Convergent Hunting Solutions Bullet HP Complete Game Calling System

With a 10-hour runtime, wireless control and IP64 weather resistance, the Bullet HP is an electronic game-calling system made right here in the USA. Thanks to a powerful 10W internal amplifier, the Bullet HP bluetooth-operated speaker is capable of exceeding 100 dBs at wireless distances of up to 300 feet.

The Armed Citizen® Jan. 24, 2022

Read today's "The Armed Citizen" entry for real stories of law-abiding citizens, past and present, who used their firearms to save lives.

New For 2022: Bergara Premier MgLite Rifle

New for 2022, Bergara introduces its new Premier Series MgLite rifle, combining carbon fiber and magnesium construction for an ultra-lightweight, long-range bolt action.

New For 2022: Stoeger STR-9C Optic Ready

New for 2022, Stoeger introduces a new addition to its compact STR-9C handgun line with an optic read model, the STR-9C Optic Ready.

New For 2022: Browning X-Bolt Speed Ovix Suppressor Ready

Browning introduces a new addition to the X-bolt Speed series for 2022 with a suppressor ready model with pre-threaded barrel.

Interests



Get the best of American Rifleman delivered to your inbox.