The Keefe Report: 1911 Pistols Then and Now

by
posted on January 13, 2021
** When you buy products through the links on our site, we may earn a commission that supports NRA's mission to protect, preserve and defend the Second Amendment. **
keefe.jpg

Colt Super .38Up to March 29, 1911, the official military hand arm of the United States was the Colt’s .38 caliber revolver. But on that day, as a result of the movement of powerful forces too strong to be resisted and which have been acting for very long, that good old revolver became obsolete and in its stead there was marked for the holsters of this Nation’s defenders the .45 Colt’s automatic; the latest, the most deadly, the finest and the best hand arm which had yet to be produced by man.”

Those words are from an April 6, 1911, article in these pages entitled, “The Greatest Pistol In The World.”  For the vast majority of its existence, the U.S. Model of 1911, followed by the M1911A1—or the commercial Government Model—was synonymous with “forty-five.” If you said that or wrote “.45,” everyone knew not only what cartridge you were talking about, but what gun as well.

That said, there have been exceptions, including guns in .455 Webley produced for the British during World War I, and then in 1928 Colt introduced the Super .38, chambered, of course, in .38 Super. Colt touted the Super .38 as, “For the big game hunter and the lover of the outdoors, the Super .38 offers an arm of unsurpassed power and efficiency … . Will stop any animal on the American Continent and is a favorite as an auxiliary arm for big game hunting trips.” The gun went rimfire in 1931 with the .22 Long Rifle Ace. There have been others, including the .38 AMU, .30 Luger and even 9 mm Steyr, but none challenged the .45 ACP for supremacy.

But the dominance of the .45 ACP M1911 has been chipped away at in more recent years. This month, we reviewed a Kimber Rapide Black Ice chambered in 10 mm Auto. If any pistol cartridge can live up to the promise of Colt’s above-mentioned marketing hype, it’s the 10 mm. The weight of an all-steel M1911 with a full 5" barrel makes the recoil of a full-power 10 mm loads if not quite pleasant, then certainly manageable.

The bigger story today, though, is the M1911 platform chambered in 9 mm Luger, particularly in the 41/4"-barreled Commander size. The aluminum-frame Commander in 9 mm made its way into Colt’s catalog in 1950 where it sat alone until other makers began offering them starting in the 1980s. The popularization of the 9 mm cartridge in the Commander-size M1911 had to wait for improvement in defensive 9 mm Luger ammunition, which is a more recent development.  

There is a very well-written and well-reasoned story by Field Editor Justin Dyal about the “The Rise Of The 9 mm M1911” you can read here. Adopted by the German army for the Luger pistol in 1908, the 9 mm Parabellum, or 9 mm Luger, is perhaps more of an American cartridge than a German one today. In terms of all guns currently produced, those in 9 mm Luger far outstrip those in .45 ACP.

On our January 2021 issue cover is a Colt Lightweight Commander built to Field Editor Wiley Clapp’s specifications, and you can see more on this gun in this video. Included are stocks of Wiley’s own design that bear a Germanic “9.” During World War I, the Germans issued the Mauser Broomhandle chambered in 9 mm Luger with wooden stocks engraved with a ”9” and filled in with red paint to indicate they were not chambered for the .30 Mauser. Intended as an historical homage, it may well be indicative of a turning point in M1911s.

Latest

Hearing Healthy
Hearing Healthy

Summer Suppressor Deals On Now

Whether it is a BOGO deal from SIG or free tax stamps from Guns.com and Silencer Central, there's plenty of hearing-safe savings to be had this summer.

Rifleman Report: Defending Freedom For 250 Years

"Anyone who claims not to understand the plain and simple intent of the Second Amendment—especially if that person happens to be a constitutional law professor, Supreme Court justice, congressman, senator or president—is likely hiding nefarious intent: to strip individual liberty from American citizens for the express purpose of making them susceptible to a tyrannical government."

Book Review: 2025 Traveler’s Guide To The Firearms Laws Of The Fifty States

Newly updated for 2025, the 29th edition of the Traveler’s Guide To The Firearm Laws Of The Fifty States is packed with all the need-to-know information for cross-country trekkers seeking to bring their arms along with them and remain legal in all localities.

Springfield Kuna: A PDW For The Masses

Small, yet fierce, the namesake of Springfield Armory’s latest large-format pistol is a revered forest dweller in the land of its Croatian manufacturing partner, HS Produkt. The new Kuna is poised to be just as welcome in America.

The Armed Citizen® June 30, 2025

Read today's "The Armed Citizen" entry for real stories of law-abiding citizens, past and present, who used their firearms to save lives.

Book Review: Clockwork Basilisk: The Early Revolvers Of Elisha Collier & Artemas Wheeler

The result of a decade of research, Clockwork Basilisk is a comprehensive, two-volume history of the rare revolvers that preceded the development of the well-known Colt guns of the 1830s.

Interests



Get the best of American Rifleman delivered to your inbox.