I Have This Old Gun: The Maynard Carbine

by
posted on September 4, 2024

On the eve of the American Civil War, there were a number of breechloading carbine designs available on the commercial market, and many were vying for military contracts. One such design was the Maynard carbine, developed by Maryland dentist Dr. Edward Maynard. Watch our "American Rifleman Television" I Have This Old Gun segment above to learn the history of the Maynard and see it in action on the range.

"Dr. Edward Maynard was an interesting chap. He was born in 1813 in Maryland, attended West Point for a short period of time, but he decided it wasn't really for him. He didn't do all that well," American Rifleman Field Editor Garry James said. "So he attended dental college and became one of the preeminent dentists of the 19th century in America. He was interested in lots of different things, and he took out a number of different firearms patents."

Left and right sides of a First Model Maynard cavalry carbine.

One of Dr. Maynard's well-known patents was for the Maynard tape primer, which used a roll of percussion priming tape in lieu of a percussion cap. A door in the side of the receiver retained the priming tape and also contained a gear that advanced the next bubble of priming compound up in line with the percussion nipple when the hammer was cocked. This provided the ignition for the Maynard's unique cartridge.

"It had a self-contained metallic cartridge, to a point," NRA Museums Director Phil Schreier said. "It had just a small hole drilled in the back where the spark from the percussion cap would travel to ignite it. So it didn't really have its own primer. It didn't possess the three Ps, the primer, the propellant and the projectile all in one. But it was pretty neat. Thirty-five and .50-caliber models were made."

The open breech of a Second Model Maynard carbine.

Though the Maynard wasn't adopted for military use prior to the outbreak of the Civil War, hundreds of the guns were sold to a number of southern states for use by their state militia. At the outbreak of the war, these gun were then employed by Confederate cavalry troopers.

"The Maynard carbine was a wonderfully simple design, it was wonderfully robust. It worked well, and there were no complaints from anyone regarding its use," American Rifleman Executive Editor Evan Brune said. "It's just that there were a number of designs in contention in the 1850s, and Maynard was a was in tough competition to gain contracts."

Following the establishment of the Confederacy and the firing on Fort Sumter in South Carolina, the federal government found itself in dire need of arms.

Three Maynard carbine cartridges arrayed on a blue cloth background.

"All of a sudden, the Union now is in need of carbines. They want to buy every carbine that they can get their hands on," Brune said. "So Maynard sells a bunch more of these First Model Maynard carbines to the Union, and these are equipped with this tape priming system, but unfortunately, there's a problem that befalls his grand plans. The Massachusetts Arms Company that Maynard contracts his rifle out to has a fire in 1861, and as a result, they can't make any guns, and they're down until the later part of 1863."

Demand for arms was still high once the factory re-started production, though, and thousands of Second Model Maynard carbines were produced for the Union Army until the end of the conflict in 1865.

"After the Civil War, Maynard determined that, you know, this could also be made into a sporting gun," James said. "As a matter of fact, he made some sporting rifles prior to the Civil War as well. So a number of different types of sporting guns, in different calibers, were produced from that period up to about 1890."

Man aiming a Maynard carbine on an outdoor range.

The longevity of the Maynard carbine, in all of its forms, is largely due to its simplicity, its robust construction and the ease with which it was adapted to advances in firearm technology and in the development of the self-contained metallic cartridge in particular.

"All in all, a very versatile gun," James said. "And it outlived a lot of its contemporaries."

To watch complete segments of past episodes of American Rifleman TV, go to americanrifleman.org/artv. For all-new episodes of ARTV, tune in Wednesday nights to Outdoor Channel 8:30 p.m. and 11:30 p.m. EST.

Latest

KelTec PR57
KelTec PR57

KelTec’s PR57: Thinking Outside The (Detachable) Box

KelTec has brought the stripper clip back with the thoroughly unconventional PR57—a carry pistol with an uncommon chambering, an unusual action and no box magazine.

The Armed Citizen® June 9, 2025

Read today's "The Armed Citizen" entry for real stories of law-abiding citizens, past and present, who used their firearms to save lives.

More Western States Opening Large Shooting Ranges

A number of states in the western U.S. have opened or are planning to open large, versatile ranges to serve the growing need for publicly accessible shooting spaces.

Preview: Sneaky Pete Distressed Leather Perfect Holster

More than just a fresh look made using handcrafted leather, the Sneaky Pete Distressed Leather Perfect Holster has been redesigned to accommodate extra ammunition in addition to a concealed firearm.

New For 2025: Rost Martin RM1S & RM1C Comped

Two new models joined the Rost Martin handgun lineup in 2025, one with subcompact dimensions and another with a built-in compensator that promises to reduce recoil substantially.

CMP Resumes M1911 Pistol Sales

As of January 2025, the Civilian Marksmanship Program (CMP) had resumed sales of surplus U.S. Army M1911/M1911A1 pistols to qualified U.S. citizens.

Interests



Get the best of American Rifleman delivered to your inbox.