Keefe Report: John Garand’s “Other Gun”

by
posted on April 11, 2015
** When you buy products through the links on our site, we may earn a commission that supports NRA's mission to protect, preserve and defend the Second Amendment. **

I have held John C. Garand’s Garand—serial number 1,000,000—but today I was able to hold another of the great arms designer’s guns. And odds are it is not what you think. While in Nashville at the NRA Annual Meeting & Exhibits, I was able to get behind the scenes at “NRA Gun Gurus” presented by Henry Repeating Arms. NRA’s National Firearms Museum’s Phil Schreier and Jim Supica are filming for their next season, and they had some interesting guns come in for the show’s closing segment.

When I entered the “green” room (which was really gray and chocked full of interesting people and guns), I was greeted by my friend Dr. Walt Kuleck (who has written some great gun books, including a brand new one on the Ruger 10/22, and articles in American Rifleman) and his wife Kathy. He brought two guns, one of which was a .22 Smith & Wesson Third Model Perfected single-shot target pistol. Back in the glory days of Springfield Armory, Garand used to shoot indoor pistol matches one of his frequent companions was then Maj. Julian S. Hatcher. Hatcher, of course, went on to become a major general and was longtime technical editor of American Rifleman (Hatcher shot a Colt Camp Perry, which now resides in the National Firearms Museum).

Garand was very interested in accuracy, and he appreciated good sights and a good a trigger—both hallmarks of his service rifle. This gun possessed both. Walt joked it’s condition is “NRA Pitiful,” as it was poorly stored and there is much pitting on the metal. But condition is not where this gun’s value comes from—it is from the ironclad provenance to John C. Garand, backed up by a Smith & Wesson factory letter. To find out what this gun is worth, turn into “NRA Gun Gurus” when the new season begins the last week of December on the Outdoor Channel.

 

Latest

Polish Vis 35 Radom Ihtog 1
Polish Vis 35 Radom Ihtog 1

I Have This Old Gun: Polish Vis 35 Radom

One of the lesser-known designs from the 1930s, the Vis 35 Radom is widely considered to be one of the best of the pre-World War II handguns.

Rifleman Q&A: Colt 1860 12-Notch Conversion

"At a gun show, I saw a Colt 1860 Army Richards Conversion with 12 cylinder notches instead of the usual six. The dealer was not sure whether this was original to the gun. Were these extra notches a factory variation or just some frontier gunsmith’s backroom project?"

July 2025 Sees Lowest Gun Sales Numbers In Nearly Six Years

Following a nearly six-year, record-setting run, according to the latest NICS and NSSF reports, firearm sales have dropped just slightly below a million during the month of July.

Review: Extar EP9 Carbine

Sporting polymer construction, partial compatibility with America's rifle, a unique bolt assembly and a no-lubricant-required design, American Rifleman staff decided the Extar EP9 Carbine, in 9 mm, deserved closer inspection.

New For 2025: Springfield Armory Echelon 4.0C Comp

Springfield Armory combined its innovative single-port integrated compensator with its compact striker-fired Echelon 4.0C platform to create an easily carried design that cuts down on recoil.

GrabAGun Targets New Buyers With Digital Firearm Sales Focus

GrabAGun, a Texas-based online retailer of firearms, ammunition and accessories, went public on the New York Stock Exchange on July 16, 2025, receiving $179 million in gross proceeds that the company affirmed will be used to expand its online platform and fund strategic acquisitions.

Interests



Get the best of American Rifleman delivered to your inbox.