Favorite Firearms: Sleeper Of A Star 1873 Winchester

posted on October 30, 2023
** When you buy products through the links on our site, we may earn a commission that supports NRA's mission to protect, preserve and defend the Second Amendment. **
1873 Winchester

You may wonder why a Model 1873 Winchester in .44-40 Win., with all of its bluing gone, a shortened barrel and magazine tube, a scrap metal front sight silver-soldered to the barrel, the fore-end tip welded to the barrel, the tubular magazine welded to the end tip, a badly cracked wooden fore-end, a missing lever latch, a missing rear sight elevator, two holes drilled through the trigger, the wrong buttplate, and the original buttstock replaced with a fabricated one could possibly be anyone’s favorite firearm.

The answer is simple. This is the same rifle Paul Newman used in the 1967 Western film, “Hombre.” Surprisingly, it was exactly in this condition in the film, as confirmed through careful examination of a high-resolution DVD of the film.

I obtained this rifle in 2017 from Peter Sherayko, who played “Texas Jack” Vermillion in the 1993 film, “Tombstone,” and have displayed it at numerous gun shows and related events across the country. Peter bought the rifle at auction from 20th Century Fox in the late 1980s along with a group of other firearms. The rifle was not listed or advertised as being in any specific film. To them, it was just another prop. Only when he got it home did Peter recognize it as the “Hombre” Winchester.

“20TH FOX” is stamped on the bottom of the receiver, and “5 IN 1” has been scratched on top of the receiver to indicate that the rifle is compatible with the 5-in-1 blank cartridge used interchangeably in three popular revolver chamberings and two popular rifle chamberings commonly seen in earlier Hollywood Western films. The rifle is fully functional and shoots great.

—Ronald A. Clayton

Latest

Dead Air Rxd910ti Suppressor F
Dead Air Rxd910ti Suppressor F

"9 mm Optimized, But 10 mm Capable:" Dead Air's New RXD910Ti Suppressor

The new Dead Air RXD910Ti harnesses the technology of the patented Triskelion baffle system to make for a 9 mm-optimized silencer that is also capable for use with 10 mm pistol cartridges and more.

Revisiting A World War II Marine’s Story

Secretary of War Pete Hegseth, in his speech to 800 assembled generals, admirals and senior enlisted at Quantico, Va., on Sept. 30, 2025, quoted Eugene Sledge from his timeless classic With The Old Breed published in 1981.

Review: Leupold Rendezvous Soft Cases

Looking for something better than a cheap nylon bag, but don’t need it armored for air travel? Leupold has you covered.

Preview: Hiperfire Hipertrain

Hiperfire’s Hipertrain is a cast aluminum housing into which the AR-style trigger system, safety selectors and pistol grip of the user’s choice (none of which are included) can be installed to create a trigger demonstrator/dry-fire trainer

New For 2026: Kimber 2K11 Comp

Kimber increased its 2K11 product line with the addition of two models with single-port compensators.

AR-15 vs. Bullpup Rifles: Which One Is Right For You?

Though bullpup-style rifle designs have become popular elsewhere in the world, they aren't nearly as popular with the American shooting public as the ubiquitous AR-15.

Interests



Get the best of American Rifleman delivered to your inbox.