2025 Rifle Of The Year: Smith & Wesson Model 1854

by
posted on June 5, 2025
** When you buy products through the links on our site, we may earn a commission that supports NRA's mission to protect, preserve and defend the Second Amendment. **
2025 Rifle Of The Year: Smith & Wesson Model 1854

Created 23 years ago, the Golden Bullseye Awards allow for the American Rifleman editors to publicly acknowledge those recent firearm and shooting product introductions that offered our readers exceptional innovation, performance and value.

“The Golden Bullseye Awards are our way of honoring those companies that introduced products of remarkable utility, innovation and simple excellence to shooters and hunters during the past year,“ said Mike Sanford, deputy executive director of NRA Media. “We congratulate the winners, and we are confident that shooters and hunters will receive this year‘s winning products with enthusiasm.”

American Rifleman September 2024 magazine cover featuring Smith & Wesson Model 1854 lever-action rifles

Although the process for our staff is a difficult one with many great selections to choose from, we are pleased to announce the 2025 Rifle Of The Year Award goes to Smith & Wesson for its Model 1854 lever-action rifle.


2025 Rifle Of The Year: Smith & Wesson Model 1854
The Smith & Wesson brand hadn’t really been associated with lever-action rifles since the company’s founding more than 170 years ago, which was just one of many reasons why Editor In Chief Brian Sheetz was keen to check out the company’s new Model 1854 family of lever guns upon their launch.

Magazine spread for Smith & Wesson Model 1854 lever-action gun review

As covered in the story “Full Swing,” Sheetz found that his .44 Mag.-chambered test rifle was well-crafted and had a smooth action thanks to numerous internal mechanical tweaks that enhanced its reliability and performance. His testing included success in the field with a Model 1854 during a Tennessee hog hunt. “Horace and Dan B. would likely be amazed at the new Model 1854’s refinement—its smoothness and firepower—and at how the company is in full-swing and has come full-circle since the days they founded it.” Sheetz said. “They would no doubt be proud, too.”

Magazine article spread with snippet overlay text on image

The rest of the editors agreed with his assessment; for contributing such a high-performing new option to an already waxing segment of the rifle market, we awarded the S&W Model 1854 Rifle Of The Year

Latest

Keltec Pr3at 1
Keltec Pr3at 1

The PR-3AT: KelTec's Magazine-Free .380

At its heart, the KelTec PR-3AT is a compact concealed-carry pistol chambered in .380 ACP that uses the same rotary-barrel and top-loading, magazine-free design as the PR57.

The 1911 DS Warrior: Kimber's Budget-Priced Double-Stack

With its new 1911 DS Warrior, Kimber is offering a more affordably priced option to handgun enthusiasts looking for a do-it-all double-stack that still retains key 1911 features.

Staccato Expands HD Lineup With C4X Carry Models

Staccato announced a new flagship model in its HD line of guns at SHOT Show 2026: the HD C4X.

Deciphering (Mostly Nonsensical) Cartridge Nomenclature

If you’re perplexed by the naming practices used by our wildcatting forefathers and cartridge makers but are still curious about what they mean, read on.

The Armed Citizen® Jan. 19, 2026

Read today's "The Armed Citizen" entry for real stories of law-abiding citizens, past and present, who used their firearms to save lives.

"9 mm Optimized, But 10 mm Capable:" Dead Air's New RXD910Ti Suppressor

The new Dead Air RXD910Ti harnesses the technology of the patented Triskelion baffle system to make for a 9 mm-optimized silencer that is also capable for use with 10 mm pistol cartridges and more.

Interests



Get the best of American Rifleman delivered to your inbox.