Two .38s

posted on July 14, 2009

Occasionally, the relationship between the .38 S&W and .38 S&W Special rounds comes up in discussion. Both cartridges were developed for and first used in Smith & Wesson revolvers. The slightly shorter .38 S&W came along circa 1877 and was designed for a succession of breaktop revolvers beginning with the Baby Russian.

About 20 years later, the company wanted an improved .38 cartridge for their medium-frame Hand Ejector known as the Military & Police model. Somewhat longer and more powerful, the .38 S&W Special was the result. It became one of the bread and butter cartridges of the 20th Century. It is still made in many loadings, as is the M&P revolver.

Oddly enough, that K frame revolver was also used for hundreds of thousands of .38 S&W revolvers for forces of the United Kingdom during WWII. The Brits used it with a 200-grain round nosed bullet and called it the .38/200.

It is important to understand that the .38 S&W Special is not a lengthened version of the .38 S&W. The shorter and less powerful .38 S&W is larger in case and bullet diameter and usually will not slide into a .38 Special chamber.

Beware of WWII British surplus S&W revolvers which had their chambers lengthened to take .38 Specials. They didn't work well because the rear of the chamber was oversized for the larger .38 S&W round. Hot .38 Specials often split when fired in one of these mutilated guns.

If in doubt, take it to a competent gunsmith for examination. In a proper revolver, the old .38 S&W – still loaded by Remington – is a good cartridge.



Rifleman Q&A: Bullet & Primer Sealant

From the archives of American Rifleman, one NRA member questions the importance of the colorful or black-colored paint-like coating around the cartridge necks and primer pockets of surplus ammunition.

Preview: Zero Tolerance Knives 0357BW

The U.S.-made Zero Tolerance 0357 Black Wash liner lock features a 3.25" blade of hard, wear-resistant CPM 20CV steel treated with a scratch-hiding blackwash finish best suited for everyday carry.

The French FR F2 Sniper Rifle

Conceived during the Cold War and after thirty years of service, the French are beginning to phase out the FR F2 bolt-action sniper rifle, with the surplus rifles available for sale from Navy Arms.

SIG Sauer P210: The Long-Lived Swiss Service Pistol

First designed in 1947, and formerly the official sidearm of the Swiss Army, the SIG Sauer P210 is still in production today, with a few modern upgrades.

The Winchester Model 94: History & Disassembly

Compact, reliable and powerful, Winchester's Model 1894 lever-actions may not have the popularity it once had with Western settlers, prospectors, law enforcement officers, hunters and ranchers, but its legacy remains today and is a fan favorite in Winchester's current product line.

NRA Gun of the Week: Fabarm USA Autumn

On this week’s “Gun of the Week” video preview, American Rifleman examines a first from Fabarm, a side-by-side break-action shotgun called the Autumn.


Get the best of American Rifleman delivered to your inbox.