Two .38s

posted on July 14, 2009

Occasionally, the relationship between the .38 S&W and .38 S&W Special rounds comes up in discussion. Both cartridges were developed for and first used in Smith & Wesson revolvers. The slightly shorter .38 S&W came along circa 1877 and was designed for a succession of breaktop revolvers beginning with the Baby Russian.

About 20 years later, the company wanted an improved .38 cartridge for their medium-frame Hand Ejector known as the Military & Police model. Somewhat longer and more powerful, the .38 S&W Special was the result. It became one of the bread and butter cartridges of the 20th Century. It is still made in many loadings, as is the M&P revolver.

Oddly enough, that K frame revolver was also used for hundreds of thousands of .38 S&W revolvers for forces of the United Kingdom during WWII. The Brits used it with a 200-grain round nosed bullet and called it the .38/200.

It is important to understand that the .38 S&W Special is not a lengthened version of the .38 S&W. The shorter and less powerful .38 S&W is larger in case and bullet diameter and usually will not slide into a .38 Special chamber.

Beware of WWII British surplus S&W revolvers which had their chambers lengthened to take .38 Specials. They didn't work well because the rear of the chamber was oversized for the larger .38 S&W round. Hot .38 Specials often split when fired in one of these mutilated guns.

If in doubt, take it to a competent gunsmith for examination. In a proper revolver, the old .38 S&W – still loaded by Remington – is a good cartridge.


Bergara Premier Mglite Rifle
Bergara Premier Mglite Rifle

New For 2022: Bergara Premier MgLite Rifle

New for 2022, Bergara introduces its new Premier Series MgLite rifle, combining carbon fiber and magnesium construction for an ultra-lightweight, long-range bolt action.

New For 2022: Stoeger STR-9C Optic Ready

New for 2022, Stoeger introduces a new addition to its compact STR-9C handgun line with an optic read model, the STR-9C Optic Ready.

New For 2022: Browning X-Bolt Speed Ovix Suppressor Ready

Browning introduces a new addition to the X-bolt Speed series for 2022 with a suppressor ready model with pre-threaded barrel.

New For 2022: Kelbly's Inc. Nanook MG Rifle

New for 2022, Kelby's Inc. unveils its ultra-lightwight Nano MG precision rifle, offered in three different calibers.

First Look: Walther PDP Color Options

Building off the success of its PDP handguns, Walther Arms now offers three additional color options for the frames of the PDP line.

New For 2022: Black Collar Arms MBA

New for 2022, Black Collar Arms releases it Modern Bolt Action, or MBA, straight-pull, bolt-action rifle which uses commonly available AR-10 parts in its construction.


Get the best of American Rifleman delivered to your inbox.