Iain Harrison: Top Shot Finale

I must confess that when the AmericanRifleman.org folks approached me to provide my insight on "Top Shot," I was a little bit hesitant. I'm really not a TV kind of guy, but they persisted. I guess my take is somewhat akin to a kid in Willy Wonka's factory—there's a ton of stuff happening that looks cool, but I have no idea what it does so please take any views offered with a basketball-size grain of salt. What has been interesting is the way the show has gotten bigger and better, and how it has brought many non-shooters into the fold. I've talked to a lot of people who've seen the show and want to go shooting as a direct result. So, if you have a similar encounter, please take the time to show them just how safe, satisfying and challenging our hobby can be.


OK, now that the Public Service Announcement is over, it’s time to get back to the action. It seems like the producers received a lot of positive feedback on the Season 1 finale and word came down to the effect of, "Great. Now make it bigger." The art department rose to the challenge, and the first bout was a doozy. Riffing on the dueling-tree theme, the sliding shutters inserted a new dimension into the competition. The problem posed was whether to concentrate on one's own targets, shut out the opposition or combine the strategies. Joe looked a little lost when faced with the constantly changing target array, which surprised me as he was very focused when shooting swinging plates.


The HORSE challenge was an obvious fan favorite and I hope it becomes a fixture of the show. The chance to capitalize on an opponent's weaknesses adds a strategic component to the competition. This mental aspect is, for me, the most intriguing part of the shooting sports, and last night, George really messed with a lot of people's heads. I recall cautioning viewers to remain detached from the character portrayals and to remember the power of editing if we wish to gain a true perspective of the very real people on our screen. At a bare minimum, George sacrificed a 50-percent chance at the prize money and, quite possibly, 100k in order to help out a friend. Any armchair quarterbacks want to bag on him now?


The mano-a-mano aspect of the final showdown between Brian and Chris was a nail-biter all the way to the final firearm. I was pleased to see each man's favorite firearm featured equally—Chris simply doesn't miss with a bow and Gunny is pure poetry with a 1911—so the two of them trading paint as they raced down the course had everyone cheering like it was the Daytona 500. In the end, it came down to whoever could shut out the 3 million people watching over his shoulder and just shoot. That guy was Chris and I applaud him for it.


So, we have a new champion. He's a good guy with a great strength of character and I hope you get the opportunity to know him a little better. For all of the drama portrayed and criticized, "Top Shot" has done more for the shooting community in the last year than any other single program, and it's worthy of support.


Share |

Comments

ADD YOUR COMMENT

Enter your comments below, they will appear within 24 hours


Your Name


Your Email


Your Comment

6 Responses to Iain Harrison: Top Shot Finale

dft wrote:
May 12, 2011

All during the season, George showed he was a little kid that needed to grow up. The trash talk is sickening, and his need for attention as well. You are a man now (or should be), act like one. I can respect him for his duty to our country and the skill he displayed. As a person, I wouldn't waste my breath talking to him as he gains his self worth by dumping on everyone else. Maybe in that last episode, George displayed a tiny bit of potential to grow as a person... I hope so. Ian, if the portrayal of the personnel on the show is all "Hollywood" creating heroes and villians and I owe George and apology, then so be it (it is offered). I do realize that the show is not just about markmanship, if it was, George would have won the 1000 yd shot challenge (and he did deserve to... he made the shot in one attempt, no one else did).

RyanSF wrote:
April 29, 2011

George is if nothing else, loyal. I'm certain it comes from his character as well as his camaraderie in the service. From a purely competitive sporting event in which the goal is to find the best single shooter and have his or her performance tested repeatedly and for that person to demonstrate consistently a high level of shooting, the protect your own behavior George exhibited and that of his group within the red team undermines the possibility that the best shooting would come out of the competition. It was evident from the major stumbles that three of the final four had in the last three challenges leading up to the final. In my opinion, the best shooting actually came out of the elimination rounds.

Steve T. wrote:
April 28, 2011

Great recap Iain! Your prose is the most entertaining around. Your insight is second to none since you were the first Top Shot. I'm looking forward to season 3. I found Jamie's interview with Cheaper Than Dirt fascinating in that he met up with Ashley in Afghanistan and they are close now. I would like to see the editing focus more on the positive than the negative. I realize the negative 10 seconds of drama is interesting, but I'd rather see the apologies too.

Jim McCausland wrote:
April 28, 2011

There are more important things than winning. Like giving a friend a chance to get back into the game at the risk of losing 100K and the title of Top Shot. George realized that his comment about what he was going to do with 100k sounded selfish when compared to what Chris and Brian said I think George reconsidered how important it was to win. I think on any given day any of the three could have been the Top Shot. It shows great character what George did. If this was any other reality show this would never happen. The other reality shows it seem like they get greedy. Which I never watch. Who wants to see a bunch of jerks. I hope Top Shot stays focus on the competition and how great the shooting sports can be. The shooters I compete with really don't like the competitors who try and win by being jerks. So I know they would not like Top Shot if it was comprised of Jerks. Keep selecting shooters like George, Brian, and Chris. PS I like competing with Iain who also has great character.

Reader 2 wrote:
April 28, 2011

I still think Ashley has some explaining to do and "man up" with Jaimie. I have complete respect for what he has done for our country but lost a lot of respect for him as a person.

reader wrote:
April 28, 2011

I still don’t like George and am glad he didn’t win. Regardless of the editing, he kept saying elimination should be chosen by performance, but when friends of his should have gone up on performance, he wasn’t willing to put them up. This makes him a liar and a hypocrite. You can’t have it both ways, and be considered to have any honor.