Pull the Slide

I’ve often wondered why the TV self-defense experts always rack the slide when performing a speed reload on a semi-auto handgun rather than releasing the slide via the slide stop. I always though it was to provide that extra eighth-of-an-inch of spring power to ensure the gun went fully into battery.


Since this has never been an issue with my Kimber, I’ve always used my thumb on my support hand to release the slide stop, bringing the gun into battery. I’ve always felt this technique is faster since my thumb could release the slide stop with my hand on the grip in my shooting position. I have used this technique in numerous competitions where reloads were required and in hours of training without ever having the gun fail to go into battery.


So, when I was at Gunsite, Ed Stock was running us through both tactical and speed reloads and he specifically said to release the slide by pulling it back after inserting the magazine. This was my opportunity to ask why he recommended pulling the slide rather than using the slide stop.


He answered: “It’s a slide stop, not a slide release. And, we train for every handgun.”


His philosophy made sense as not every handgun has an easily accessible slide stop. The slide stop on the Smith & Wesson M&Ps we were using is much smaller than the one on my Kimber, and as such, would be much harder to release under pressure, especially with sweaty or grimy hands. Many other handgun models also have small slide stops that could be difficult to release when needed most, so eliminating that element ensures consistent speed when reloading regardless of the model of handgun.


How do you return the gun to battery when reloading?


Share |

Comments

ADD YOUR COMMENT

Enter your comments below, they will appear within 24 hours


Your Name


Your Email


Your Comment

8 Responses to Pull the Slide

JP wrote:
June 28, 2011

What method do you use to clear a type one malfunction...tap/rack. If you utilize this single method that accounts for a number of different actions...bringing a round into battery, reloading, clearing a jam, cycling a squib/defective round out of the action. Then when faced with any number of reasons for returning your firearm to battery to include reloading, you are practicing an action that accounts for the other reasons as well.

FatBoy52 wrote:
June 26, 2011

I, too, have questioned the rationale behind the "rack the slide" wisdom. I never considered the thought about using another gun without an easy-to-use release (my CZ-75 P01 has a large, easy-to-use release). Since this is my primary (only) handgun for self-defense, I think I can downplay that one, at least for me. I have heard the "fine motor skills" argument before. My question to that is, "How did you release the empty magazine?" That required "fine motor skills" use of the same thumb that you use to release the slide. I believe this point renders that argument completely moot. I have trained for years using my thumb to release, and I have become very quick about it. Until I hear a really compelling argument against it, I will continue to do so.

Gary wrote:
June 17, 2011

Wow what a question as for me my first pistol shot was a 9 mm Lugar my dad brought back from ww II at the age of 5 I now you have to rack the toggle on the reload to go into battery, 14 years later I was a new medic in the 82nd Airborne and had to fire the 1911a1 there they taught us to use the release to go into battery and for the last 32 years for me it's been the 1911,and nothing else for a primary weapon, I was shooting the 1911 when it wasn't cool, everybody wanted the next best thing. I've got 3 1911's and never had the problem. My friend would laugh at me , until my target was just one big hole in the center and there's looked liked Swiss cheese. With all the junk being said I watch the shows I think the guys are like you said shooting a weapon that's trying to be the next best thing but it just don't measure up to the 1911 standards were the release is hard to press or maybe it just looks cool. Us old timers laugh at theses kids on the tv and at the range trying to look cool but can't hit a thing . This is not a put down on how other folks shoot and operate there firearms it just an observation. Thanks

James Dulin wrote:
June 07, 2011

I always rack the slide. I'm a Mechanical Engineer who realizes that if you release the slide with the slide stop over time it will round over the notch in the slide and can cause problems. It may take years, but eventually it will happen, even in hardened steel. As was pointed out in this article, it's a slide stop, not a slide release. Use it as designed.

Rob Firriolo wrote:
June 07, 2011

I train my students to rack the slide, not depress the slide lock. Mr. Stock's rationale is correct. Moreover, depressing a slide lock with a finger is a fine motor skill; racking the slide with a hand is a gross motor skill. Gross motor skills are likely to be more useful in stressful situation.

Tony Kammerer wrote:
June 07, 2011

I've always preferred the slide stop method myself as every gun I have fired has been easy to release with it, but I do think this makes sense as in a pinch I can see it as a potential cause for clumsiness. Any reason not to train for the slide stop method followed by pull slide method if needed? Would make ever reload a bit faster except the one with the unfamiliar or troublesome slide stop lever and I think being faster almost always would be good.

Nathan wrote:
June 06, 2011

Slide release lever, strong hand. If you always train with one gun - your carry gun - you don't have to worry about different platforms. And it's much faster.

Miketango71 wrote:
June 06, 2011

I train to pull the slide for the exact reason listed by the instructor; it is a slide stop. I teach all my students this.