Experts in the Field
FacebookTwitter
YouTubeRSS Feed
10 Movie Myths Dispelled (page 2)

10 Movie Myths Dispelled (page 2)

Gun mistakes in movies are flagrant and often. Here are some of the worst.

By B. Gil Horman

  • Comment
  • Send to Friend
  • Share This

 

Sideways
No one can really say when, or why, it became cool, but according to the movies, you can greatly increase your street creds and intimidation factor by holding a semi-automatic pistol in just one hand while turning it so the sights are off to one side. Just tip your head, look down your arm to the back of your hand, sight in along the side of the pistol’s slide and let your gangsta coolness fill the room like cheap cologne.

The good news is that semi-auto pistols can operate omni-directionally. In other words, the action will cycle regardless of the pistol's orientation. A pistol can fire on its side, or even upside down, and it will keep firing until the magazine is empty. The real question is what kind of accuracy can be expected from this improvisational aiming technique. Lets just say it will cost you less than a whole box of pistol cartridges fired gangsta-style at the range to find out why there isn't a Shooting Sideways 101 class offered at Gunsite Academy  or Thunder Ranch.

Stand and Deliver (Your Lines)
Making movies is the art of stuffing a 3-dimensional world into a 2-dimensional format to create a convincing optical illusion. At the heart of all good filming is the proper use of camera angles. Unfortunately, the layout of the real world and the way people move through it isn't conducive to good camera work. So, the directors and actors throw out common sense behavior in favor of movements and poses that look nifty on screen.

The director orders a tight close up of the hero's face but he needs to show the pistol as well. Let's have the actor move his pistol from a realistic low-ready position and hold it up near his or her face with the muzzle pointed at the ceiling. There, that looks much better on camera. A trained soldier would crouch down behind protective cover to return fire. But we can't see Mr. Schwarzenegger's pectorals popping when he's hunkered down behind that garden wall. Tell him to stand up nice and tall so we can see him clearly. The screen play reaches a critical moment where any normal person would run for it, but having the actor run would make him look like a sissy. We’ll maintain his tough-guy image by having him casually stroll through the hail of bullets…. Are you getting the big picture?

Don’t Stand There—Shoot
This is probably the most aggravating reoccurring self-defense scene in all of movieland and a complete insult to women. Julia, a beautiful young wife, is home all alone while her husband is out saving the city. She steps gently, barefoot and vulnerable, to her bed to lie down for a night's rest. Suddenly, the Serial Killer appears in her doorway and unleashes his evil laugh! Julia shrieks! The murderer steps closer. Julia reaches into her night stand and pulls out a cocked-and-locked Para USA 14-45 1911 .45 ACP pistol. Releasing the safety, Julia levels the pistol at the advancing maniac’s center of mass. The Serial Killer stops, holds up his hands and begins to talk quietly to the frightened woman.

With 15 rounds of 230-grain +P hollow points aimed and ready to fire at the most dangerous psychopath the city has ever known, Julia chooses to listen. As the Serial Killer slowly advances, describing everything from the atrocities he has perpetrated to the bagel and coffee he had for breakfast that morning, Julia melts into a quivering, whimpering lump of Jello. With just one more step, the Serial Killer reaches out and gently lifts the powerful semi-auto from Julia's trembling fingers and gives her a knowing smile.

Are you kidding me? The women I know who practice legal concealed carry would never allow this kind of victimization to take place. They have developed the proper defensive mindset. While these wonderful wives and mothers have no desire to harm anyone, they are mentally prepared and properly armed to stand up to a threat if one arises. Statistics show that more women are choosing to go armed and to participate in defensive training than ever before. If assailants don’t want to become a statistic themselves, it’s time for them to take up another occupation.

Evaporating Bullets
With all of the silliness surrounding guns and shooters in big-budget movies, no action flick would be complete without including at least one Magical Bullet special effect. We have Ol’ Sparky, the lead handgun slug that produces a shower of sparks when it strikes a metallic surface near one of the characters. Then there’s the rocket-propelled grenade (RPG) pistol bullet. This round will turn any humble vehicle with a gas tank into a raging inferno. But the most worrisome bullet effect in movies, from a self-defense perspective, is the complete lack of a special effect. It could be called the Evaporating Bullet. These are the rounds fired into various environments and objects without producing any impact results at all.

Actors have it easy because their firearms are loaded with blanks. The only consequence they have to face for a carelessly aimed shot is another take. In the real world, once a bullet leaves a gun, it’s going to hit something. More likely than not, the object the bullet strikes and damages will be of value to someone else. One instructor said it this way: “Just imagine there’s a little lawyer attached to each bullet you fire.” Beyond the legal implications of stray shots are the moral implications of harming an innocent bystander. While awareness of what lies beyond your target is an important safety practice in practice, it’s even more critical in a defensive situation.

  • Comment
  • Send to Friend
  • Share This

Comments

  • EMP

    10/8/2012 5:33:37 PM

    Still haven't seen my biggest pet peeve here. The Mythbusters have disproved this one muliple times over but Hollyweird insists on still using it. It's the bubble trail of rounds traveling through water seemingly at full speed 15 feet under and occasionally hitting the good guy. It has been definitively shown that the smallest .22 up to a 50 cal. will all break up and stop completely within 2-3 feet of entering the water. The water is too dense and acts as the worlds most plentiful and natural body armor there is. Enough already Hollywood!!

  • Denny

    10/5/2012 11:09:06 PM

    "The Rifleman" runs off three or four shots, then spins the rifle all the way around. Wouldn't it fire again as the lever hits the right spot?

  • Tommy

    9/27/2012 1:30:39 PM

    I haven't seen this one written about yet. The law enforcement person just starting a gunfight, fires TWO rounds and the pistol slide locks back, out of ammo! Who goes into a gunfight with less than a full magazine! It allows the crook time to get the drop on the good guy and lecture him for ten minutes about why he is going to kill him. The 10 minute speech though allows the SWAT time to show up and shoot the bad guy!

  • Jp

    9/25/2012 11:53:33 PM

    My favorite is always hearing a hammer being cocked on glocks or any striker fired pistols.

  • Paul

    9/25/2012 5:02:34 PM

    Liked the movie "Flyboys" but cringed at some of the weird flying sequences,... never have seen bi-planes with jet fighter like performances, and what the hell were those smoking little RPG's supposed to be? And I can't imagine anybody in their right mind banging on a receiver with a little hammer in the middle of a dog-fight! And in "Red Tails" our hero takes out a Naval vessel with one or two strafing runs, and wipes out a flight of Me 262 jets! Rock on Hollywood ! Gotta luv the hookieness!

  • Steven Peters

    9/24/2012 10:00:43 PM

    For solid police procedure and appropriate gun handling, watch episodes of Adam-12 (on Netflix). Jack Webb was evidently not just close to LAPD technical advisors, but a stickler for accuracy.

  • centercut

    9/21/2012 11:51:00 AM

    Re Movie Myths you did not include my two favorites. First is the ridiculous performance of cap and ball revolvers in Eastwood Civil War era movies. Spent caps never jam (as they often do) as the movie revolver is rapid fired or even fanned. Second is the impossible accuracy of movie cowboy gunslingers as they show off shooting cans or coins out of the air with never miss rapid fire from the hip no less.

  • bleukahuna

    9/20/2012 10:19:41 PM

    Comments...The movie RED had lots of comical firearms mis-use, can't say which was more fun, the mega revolver takeing out a RPG in mid flight or Helen Mirren running an M2!

  • Bulleteer

    9/19/2012 9:23:21 AM

    Remember "Superman" with George Reeves? Crook empties his revolver at Superman. We see the bullets glancing off the Man of Steel's chest. Crook then throws empty gun at our hero. What does Superman do? He ducks!

  • Daniel

    9/19/2012 7:46:35 AM

    Mly favorite was an old Hawaii Five O episode where the mob guy checks his snubbie three times before Steve and the boys settle accounts with him. Once when he pulls it out to leave home, but then again each time he gets ready to exit the car. Really? Are you that senile?

  • Mayman

    9/18/2012 7:58:18 PM

    Anybody notice that TV/Movie guns are so quiet. A gun that in real life that would be earsplittingly loud makes a quiet puttering noise when fired on TV or in a movie, with no silencer used on the gun.

  • Wheelman

    9/17/2012 1:31:54 AM

    Talking or even yelling after firing indoors is impossible. My buddy once put a .22 thru the ceiling accidentally. My other friend and I were screaming at him afterward, and nobody could hear a word of it. I didnt even really hear the shot, as much as feel it cuz my ears just started ringing instantly. We were completely deaf for 10 - 15 secs and the ringing lasted minutes. Have a friend box your ears with flat palms as hard as he can then yell something at you. You wont hear it

  • gunguy

    9/12/2012 7:57:07 AM

    How about when the good guy is running down a hallway or corridor of some sort, with multiple bad guys firing fully automatic weapons at him, but they all miss! A whole wall of bullets, and not a single hit. Nice.

  • Phil

    8/31/2012 2:28:03 PM

    I like the scene in the 1987 movie "Overboard" with Goldie Hawn, Kurt Russell and Edward Herrmann. When Goldie’s husband (Edward Herrmann) is shooting skeet off of the bow of their luxury yacht with a break-action side-by-side double-barreled shotgun, but after every shot you hear the racking sound of a pump shotgun!

  • L33tg33k

    8/25/2012 6:24:52 PM

    My favorite is when the good and bad guys have a massive gunfight and they show the aftermath. You see 20-30 machine guns and only a couple of shells on the floor, maybe fewer than 20! And I lost count of how many times the rifles NEVER show the shells being ejected!

  • Retired Educator.

    8/13/2012 5:11:41 AM

    Sideways pistols may be hard to hit anything but are you willing to stand i front of someone wildly firing bullets in your direction??? My most accurate gun is a S&W snubbie. My hardest to shoot accurately is that same snubbie. Properly stabilized, it doesn't matter how long the barrel is !!!

  • Jim

    8/6/2012 5:24:00 PM

    My ex-wife is a detective novel and movie fan and aspiring author of same, but she'd never fired or even held a firearm when we met. We'd watched all kinds of movies and TV shows with gunfight scenes without her commenting, then I taught her to shoot; she learned fast and got pretty good. The next time she saw a TV show hero turn after the villain shot at him (and missed, of course), whip his snubby revolver from his shoulder holster, and pick the bad guy off a rooftop from a block away, she jumped to her feet, pointed at the TV, and shouted, "Nobody could make that shot!" I like to think that perhaps I slightly improved the quality of anything she ended up writing.

  • Gene

    8/5/2012 1:21:09 PM

    I like Chuck Norris' Texas Ranger pickup truck. It sparks real nice when shot, but there's never a hole or even a scratch. I guess they're afraid of really!!! ticking off Chuck Norris.

  • Texasjack

    8/5/2012 1:49:39 AM

    The sideways shot came about because some high-paid actor got hot brass in his face, so director John Woo came up with a way to shoot that would toss the brass away from them. As for the Evaporating Bullet, has anyone wondered how Annie Oakley could shoot glass balls tossed in the air with a rifle while surrounded by an audience? Some years ago a box of ammo she left behind was found in England. The "bullets" were made of thin wood and filled with bird shot. They kinda did 'evaporate' and not hit the audience. One of the worse offenders was a movie called "Man from the Alamo" with Glenn Ford. He's shown travelling through the desert from San Antonio to San Jacinto (near present day Houston). Umm, there is no desert there! He also loads cartridges into his revolver. Oops, revolvers didn't show up in any numbers in Texas until 10 years after the battle at the Alamo and didn't use cartridges for 40 more years. I think your list also left off the guys who shoot two fully automatic machine guns, one in each hand!

  • Karl Hart

    8/4/2012 10:05:48 PM

    The best real stunt with racking an 870 Remington I witnessed on the job. A druggy decided to break into the Drug Fair store on Westbard Avenue in Bethesda, MD, some 20 years ago. An insomniac across the street in a high rise heard the racket of the druggy try to chop through the roof with an axe. He called police. We surrounded the building. Soon the druggy figured out the cops were present. He decided to shinny down the downspout to get away. Half way down, he lost his grip & landed in a heap in the snow. My partner racked a perfectly good round out into the snow, just for the effect, while pointing the shotgun at the druggy's nose. Street theatrics at it's best!

  • Madjack

    8/3/2012 2:23:53 PM

    What I want to see is frivolous lawsuits against the film institute, producer, director, &/or actor when some mental freakazoid copies their actions in real life. Let's watch them explain their actions, for once..

  • GMJ

    8/3/2012 12:31:19 AM

    The one movie effect that makes me cringe is seeing full auto weapons being fired that produce muzzle flashes that are as long as the barrel itself. Movie armorers load blank rounds with slow burning powder that produces huge flashes for dramatic effect. In reality, I can't think of a better way to announce to your enemies, "Here I am! Shoot over here!"

  • Left Coast Chuck

    8/2/2012 8:04:34 PM

    I like the scenes where the gun holder opens the cylinder on a double action revolver, spins the cylinder and then nonchalantly flips the cylinder closed. What's he checking for? Doesn't he remember whether he loaded his weapon or not? Has he had that many shootings that he can't remember whether he loaded his Dick Special after the last shootout?

  • jimonthebeach

    8/2/2012 7:48:19 PM

    I think most of my complaints about Hollywood gun fights have been covered, but the one that still sticks in my craw occurred on Miami Vice. Sonny Crockett and his partner took on a hundred or more drug smugglers and killed dozens of them. When their backup arrives after the gun battle is over, Sonny and partner just jump into their Ferrari and drive away. No debriefing, no reports, no evidence collection, no IA investigators, just left the scene and bodies to the late arriving swat team.

  • John

    8/2/2012 6:14:57 PM

    Often, a gun is shot near someone in the dirt or against a wall with no harm done, when in reality, the victim would definitely experience damage from shrapnel or a ricochet. Scenes like this make some people think that no one will get hurt from doing this. Another one is the gunfight indoors, after which everyone is having a nice conversation and not complaining at all about their hearing loss.

  • sawdustking

    8/2/2012 5:28:11 PM

    I always liked the whispering after engaging in a gun fight with no hearing protection. It wouldn't matter whether Dirty Harry shot 5 or 6 rounds of 44 magnum, he'd be shouting just to hear himself over the ringing in his ears. I shot a .357 two times once without plugs and my ears were ringing for 2 hours.

  • ScottieG59

    7/28/2012 12:00:08 PM

    Movies would bore people to tears if things were like real life. Gun fights, car chases, hand to hand combat, love scenes, etc... I make sure my kids get the movie after action review. Sure, guns recoil, shooters have to use marksmanship, bad guys shoot back, bombs do not have a flashing light and beeper warning, most landmines use pressure triggers [(]very few use pressure release triggers[)], when the bomb detonates - you cannot simply jump away from the fluffy cloud, you can be the good guy, do things right and still lose...

  • Greg Lee

    7/25/2012 10:30:20 AM

    How about gun fights with guns that shoot 100 rounds without reloading & shooting AR's, MP5's, etc on full auto then reloading after shooting hundreds of rounds per mag. Also, guys with pistols or shot guns that they only rack slide when they confront bad guy, & not before. Who would do that? And last but not least, standard pistol grip using palm of hand to cup bottom of grip, from supposedly ppl in the business.

  • Partsfreak

    7/23/2012 7:34:18 PM

    My peeve is how several bad guys with full auto rifles are within 20 yards of the hero just spraying the area and cant hit anything. Meanwhile the hero just fires back over his shoulder and picks them off easily.

  • Paul

    7/21/2012 5:33:58 AM

    At one time the silencer on the revolver was a requirement of the movie codes, the idea being that it would prevent folks from being successful at silencing their pistols. Balance that with ads from before the 1934 GCA where there were silenced rifles being sold to farmers so they could kill the weasel or fox without hurting egg production. Auto Ordnance also had one of a cowboy in full western regalia from the 10 gallon hat down to the chaps and spurs. He is on the front porch of his cabin fighting off bad guys with a thompson with a drum magazine.

  • Pete W

    7/20/2012 10:09:54 AM

    I recently took a pistol course for concealed carry, and the instructor pointed out a couple movies that had very good gun techniques. I think this conversation would be made interesting by people volunteering good displays as infrequent as they are.

  • Dan H

    7/20/2012 6:46:43 AM

    I've always been a big fan of seeing the scenes in which people to the intimidation-slide-rack, only to ride it forward and have a FTF. Call me crazy, but a gun that can't possibly fire is my favorite kind of gun to be staring down the barrel of.

  • Ray T.

    7/19/2012 6:21:39 PM

    One of my pet peeves is the forensic specialist solemnly declaring the it was a 9mm or .357 or .38. Since they are all essentially the same size you cannot even make an intelligent guess as to caliber.

  • David J.

    7/18/2012 1:22:03 PM

    @JackAce If any of your revolvers (AKA wheelguns) were single-six models thier cylinder would rotate when closed.I do believe Movies in general are make believe or fake,but just because someone aims a pistol at me with it tilted to the side does not mean that he can not shoot straight. They may not be familiar with guns or they may know exactly what they can do with them.

  • Dave

    7/18/2012 12:06:57 PM

    Personal favorite: The Unit. Undercover SpecOps guy having a conversation with drug cartel leader. Sound of shotgun racking, camera pans to show cartel leader holding an over/under shotgun. Allrighty then.

  • weatherman

    7/18/2012 11:53:29 AM

    You got most of my peeves, but another is the ever changing firearm. You see the good guy shooting a glock in the closeup, but then in the next scene it is a Beretta or a sig, then back to a glock....

  • Uncle Rob

    7/18/2012 10:43:48 AM

    "Anaconda" when a bolt action hunting rifle (BDL?) fired 6 or 7 times without the bolt handle being touched once. A '60's spaghetti western set immediately after the U.S. Civil War where the bad guy has a broomhandle Mauser. I once saw a guy knocked backward about 6 feet by a shot, but it was a M-79 too close to arm the round. I also like SMLE's with an invisible 20 round magazine as seen "The English Patient" or was it "Captain Corelli's Mandolin"? The motion picture industry has been the single biggest detriment to firearm safety. And when was the last time Officer Friendly blew half of a perp's face off on CSI?

  • David

    7/18/2012 11:04:46 AM

    I love how every glock makes a hammer-cocking noise in the movies.

  • Russ

    7/18/2012 10:46:23 AM

    What about forgetting the safety on a glock. I have seen that one a few times.

  • Philip

    7/18/2012 10:43:35 AM

    it drives me crazy when you see a high caliber pistol being rapid fired with no recoil.

  • Anthony

    7/18/2012 9:26:39 AM

    What happens to all the spent cartridges? Even when shown, seldom does the amount in a scene equal rounds fired.

  • LCEIII

    7/18/2012 8:10:49 AM

    You missed my favorite, a revolver with a silencer!

  • Larry

    7/18/2012 7:17:35 AM

    the one i like is when they pull thier gun out of their holster and pull the magazine out to check if it is loaded. that should be done first thing on putting your gun on in the morning.

  • Pete

    7/18/2012 7:00:01 AM

    Can't resist adding my personal favorite: discussion by Kiefer Sutherland in "The Sentinel" about Secret Service vs. DC Metro Police training to flip safety switch off when drawing. Says SS flips saftey as they draw to be ready to shoot to protect President but DC police taught to leave safety on while drawing because threat is not always as immediate. Interesting concept except even in the movie SS uses SIGs and DC police use Glocks.

  • jefferis peterson

    7/18/2012 6:57:51 AM

    I am glad most criminals and "gangstas" are watching the movies and holding their pistols sideways :-)

  • JackAce

    7/18/2012 6:14:43 AM

    i hate when i see Russian roulette being played with just about any wheel gun in the world. I own several wheel guns, of varying make and manufacture but none of them spin freely when closed like you see in the movies.

  • david n

    7/18/2012 4:38:22 AM

    The most disturbing trend I've noticed is how many "heroes" are willing to disarm themselves while facing a bad guy with a hostage. Sans sniper, you're also dead or another hostage, so what's the point? Your threat is the ONLY thing keeping the bad guy in check. And if I'm within 20 feet and lined up on target, I'm taking the shot - end of story.

  • Mike Boyington

    7/18/2012 3:38:22 AM

    Racking the action on a pump shotgun can be a useful intimidtion tactic when standing your ground. Just realise you're not ready to fire until you complete this step on your use of force scale!

  • anthony

    7/18/2012 3:12:04 AM

    My favorite mistake is having 1911's click repeatedly after they run out of ammo. Many times they show the slide locked to the rear too and it still clicks when the trigger is pulled as if it were a double action revolver

  • Randy

    7/18/2012 12:43:56 AM

    You've covered most of them. Sometimes a slide will be racked several times for theatrical effect before ever firing a shot, but without spilling live rounds onto the floor. The old western ricochet sound effects have finally fallen out of fashion. There used to be a ricochet with every shot.

  • Roy

    7/18/2012 12:31:11 AM

    You guys left out the one that's made me crazy for years. When the guy with an empty semi-auto pistol repeatedly pulls the trigger and it clicks as if he's got an empty revolver. Drives me nuts.

  • James Lightner

    7/17/2012 11:41:22 PM

    The one that drives me nuts is watching some idiot screw a silencer onto a revolver. That will not work at all.

  • Crackshot

    7/17/2012 10:36:27 PM

    I can't remember the title of the movie, but, I remember a scene where the person was carrying a double-barrel shotgun. As he entered the room, you could noticably hear the "racking" of a round being chambered in a pump shotgun. I have also heard the same "racking" sound for a grenade launcher. (single shot) I thought that both were comical effects.

  • ronbwolf

    7/17/2012 10:32:51 PM

    I love the scenes, sometimes it's the whole show or movie, where the police/detectives/agents, are involved in shooting after shooting leaving a trail of dead and wounded, and never get suspended, put on leave, investigated, like in real life.

  • Florida Republican

    7/17/2012 9:12:32 PM

    My pet peeve didn't show up here. It's when pistols continue to fire even with the slide locked all the way back.

  • benelliboy

    7/17/2012 9:00:03 PM

    I always like the scenes where people are shooting semi automatic guns and they run out of ammo, and you can hear the hammer, going forward 3 or 4 times after its empty

  • Steve

    7/17/2012 8:55:30 PM

    You failed to mention the "since I couldn't hit you with all my bullets, maybe I can hit you by throwing the gun" idiocy.

  • Hicksville Kid

    7/17/2012 3:05:40 PM

    My favorite 'racking' scene in the movies was a Bruce Willis movie where he gets on a hijacked tug/barge and holds a shotgun on a perp and asks "how many of your buddies are on this boat?" They guy doesn't answer and Willis says "let me rephrase the question" and racks the shotgun resulting in the answer. Just good fun.

  • Firewagon

    7/16/2012 10:38:15 AM

    Really like the last paragraph! Mall shootings seem to be in vogue but, if you are a licensed concealed carry cat, your first and best idea might be to find that back door escape....the better part of valor, perhaps?